Menu

The Milling Room

The Milling Room, 446 Columbus Ave., New York

4.4
RESTAURANT RATING: 
EXCELLENT
4.4 out of 5 (166 Ratings)
Powered By Opentable
1.7 miles New York Historical Society
About The Milling Room
The Spotlight on The Milling Room

Classic Meets Contemporary Near Central Park

The Milling Room is a warm, inviting French-American brasserie located on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Just steps from Central Park and a short walk or quick subway ride from major concert venues like Lincoln Center and Beacon Theatre, this elegant yet unpretentious spot blends seasonal American dishes with European flair. The soaring skylit dining room and rustic-chic decor create a welcoming atmosphere that feels both refined and relaxed.

Why Concert-goers love it

Whether you’re headed to an intimate acoustic set or a grand orchestral performance, The Milling Room is a superb pre-show stop. Its proximity to popular venues makes timing stress-free, and diners regularly praise the efficient, friendly service—ideal when you’re on a tight schedule. The space stays lively without being too loud, so you can still chat about the setlist over cocktails or a glass of wine. There’s also a bar and lounge area if you’re just looking for a quick bite or drink before the curtain goes up.

Who this Restaurant is great for

  • Groups of friends looking to kick off the night with shareable plates and craft cocktails
  • Solo travelers wanting a quality meal in a welcoming setting
  • Couples planning a romantic evening around a concert or show
  • Fans seeking a stylish but relaxed pre-show atmosphere
  • Budget-conscious music lovers who appreciate value in a refined setting

What People Say

Diners love the ambience, often noting the high ceilings, natural light, and warm lighting that create a “hidden gem” feel. The menu earns praise for its fresh, seasonal ingredients and reliable favorites like the short rib, duck breast, and house-made pastas. Service is frequently described as attentive but unintrusive, and many reviewers mention it as their go-to spot before a show or event nearby.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests have noted that the noise level can rise during peak hours, so if you're looking for a quiet meal, consider arriving earlier in the evening. A few reviewers also mentioned that certain dishes, while beautifully presented, could be lighter on seasoning—but overall, the quality remains consistently high.

The Bottom Line

The Milling Room is an ideal pre-show destination for concert-goers seeking a tasteful, convenient, and reliably delicious experience in the heart of Manhattan.

Average Price
$31 to $50
Cuisine
French American
Dress Code
Smart Casual
Opening Hours
Brunch
Sat, Sun 11:00 am-3:00 pm
Dinner
Mon-Thu, Sun 5:00 pm-9:30 pm
Fri, Sat 5:00 pm-10:30 pm

The Milling Room Customer Reviews

Overall Average Score: 
Exceptional (5 out of 5)

Write a review

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Camille, Branford CT

We sat at the bar for dinner. The bartenders were friendly and professional; the food was delicious and well prepared.

Liked: Scottish salmon dish.
Disliked: Nothing.

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

The Milling Room is #904 of 14718 things to do in New York City

3 of 5 stars3 out of 5
By: Francofriend, New York
Sun 11 May, 2025
l A totally mixed experience. On the plus side: the room is pretty, the receptionists and servers were attentive, helpful and very pleasant, the portions generous. But the food was inconsistent at...

Read Full Review
4 of 5 stars4 out of 5
By: Allansha, New York City, New York
Sat 11 Jan, 2025
l The restaurant was split with a front part of a pub anesthesia large dining area with tables far apart. Which was quite nice. The menu had a number of pasta dishes meats snd fish items that pleased...

Read Full Review
1 of 5 stars1 out of 5
By: bonnevivante_travel, Paris, France
Sun 6 Oct, 2024
l Beautiful setting; Brussels sprouts and dessert delicious; service atrocious; food was undercooked and despite attempts to get it right, they did not fix it or ever check on our table to see if...

Read Full Review
Write a Review of The Milling Room
Reference (Required)
Your Name (Required)
Your City
Your Email Address (Required)
Your overall rating of The Milling Room
What was good?
What was bad?
Your review of The Milling Room
The Milling Room 446 Columbus Ave., New York