We ate at the hotel restaurant. The bed was comfortable. The room was a nice size and clean. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We valet parked our car and it was taken good care of. We would stay at the Wyndham again.

Liked: We had a nice experience at the hotel.

It's a very old hotel but it is in a fantastic location for Manhattan. The price is exceptional for a NYC hotel and it is a clean, safe place to stay. Rooms were a little small but wouldn't stop me from staying again. Friendly staff.

Liked: Great location; nice price and clean.
Disliked: Small rooms.

Not what it used to...

Liked: This hotel has a great location
Disliked: Up to floor 18 is now full of students which changes the feel of the hotel. The first room we had was tiny, and the bed was broken! The second room was better but still not worth the price we paid. We stayed here 5 years ago and it was lovely but it?s gone down hill since then.

Pricy and not convenient for...

Liked: - very good people are working in the lobby - location in Manhattan near the subway station, lots of restaurants around - in walking distance - Madison Square Garden, Empire State Building, Times Square - close to Jersey, lots of ways to get to
Disliked: Every day I had to re-register in a Wi-Fi network with email and all credentials. Only "1-day" option was available. No fridge, very small room. ?arpets in room, corridors and at the lobby are very old and had a smell of dust. Almost impossible to find a store with fresh vegetables/fruits etc

A great place for a...

Liked: We liked the location being close to Penn Street station and the subway. Not too far from Times Square and shops nearby. There were several eateries within the Wyndham and we used them as they were convenient and turned out to be fine.
Disliked: Rooms a little small but apart from that no complaints.

Good

Liked: Location is great, staff were friendly and helpful, nice to stay in classic NY hotel
Disliked: Room was a bit dark

Would never return

Disliked: Requested a room on a low floor as terrified of heights - was put on 32nd floor(!), no coffee making facilities available, requested them and never turned up, room had brown liquid on the wall, condom wrapper on the floor...no restrooms in the lobby area

Exceptional

Liked: We had a great experience in the New Yorker, 50 steps from a Metro station, 10 blocks from Times Square. An amazing placee to share with my family.

Disgusting hotel-----looks pretty when you...

Liked: location
Disliked: room smelled, small bugs in draws, unfriendly, rooms small shoes were stolen from room,and when reported security never called me back and I called 12 times !!!!!! It was a bad experience. I travel a lot with platinum Amex card and use their hotels, but friends insisted on this hotel because of location. Hotel mgr should be replaced

Good experience/friendly staff

Liked: Concierge service particularly John
Disliked: Wardrobe too small

6 different charges added onto...

Liked: location very convenient to attractions, walked to a lot of them
Disliked: room small and very dark, facing a wall of another building while paying top price