The New Yorker A Wyndham Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Joanne G, Massapequa, visiting Madison Square Garden
We ate at the hotel restaurant. The bed was comfortable. The room was a nice size and clean. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We valet parked our car and it was taken good care of. We would stay at the Wyndham again.
Liked: We had a nice experience at the hotel.
Robert G, Toms River
It's a very old hotel but it is in a fantastic location for Manhattan. The price is exceptional for a NYC hotel and it is a clean, safe place to stay. Rooms were a little small but wouldn't stop me from staying again. Friendly staff.
Liked: Great location; nice price and clean.
Disliked: Small rooms.
Anonymous Wed, 9 July 2025
Passable
Khanh Tue, 8 July 2025
Great location. Other than that,...
Liked: Location
Disliked: 1. Poor staffing, not accommodating, not knowledgeable, easy frustrated with customers 2. Bathroom dirty- mildew. Poor pressure with water and toilet.3. No free breakfast- claimed booking.com didn’t communicate with hotel.4. I booked for 3 families but claimed again booking.com only communicated 1 room ( 1 family only).
Ashley Tue, 8 July 2025
Exceptional
Merrigan Tue, 8 July 2025
Bad
Alfredo Tue, 8 July 2025
Exceptional
Otto Mon, 7 July 2025
Good aesthetic and location with...
Liked: Great location if you want to be close to the center of the action, with most of the key tourist sights in walking distance or about 15-20 minutes by public transit. The Butcher and Banker steakhouse in the basement (an old bank vault) was the highlight of our stay, and the Tick Tock Diner is convenient if you want to have a bite and don't want to stray far from the hotel.
Disliked: This hotel does not actually have queen beds even though they are advertised as such on both the hotel's website and Booking.com. The "queen" beds are actually doubles and very small for two average-sized adults. Moreover, the room does not come with a mini fridge, which was a first for us. Would have booked elsewhere for the sake of comfort had we known these things.
Benita Mon, 7 July 2025
Good
Coulas Mon, 7 July 2025
Exceptional
Christopher Mon, 7 July 2025
a good three-night stay
Liked: good central location; room air conditioning working very effectively; interesting hotel floor layout; business room available for guests in the basement; display about the history of the hotel in the basement and on the 33rd floorcentennial year approaching for this good old hotel
Disliked: kind of slow-moving revolving door between the sidewalk and the hotel lobby at the front entrance
Ruta Mon, 7 July 2025
Average
Liked: The breakfast option in the adjacent restaurant was ok for us. The best thing about the hotel - is the location (its just few minutes walk to the Penn Station)
Disliked: Its quite an old hotel and the rooms, as well as corridors are worn out. We had a room which was kind of an upgrade (we paid more), but we did not feel that we got a better room in comparison with other rooms where our family members stayed. No complimentary water is provided, no view from the window. But taking into consideration a nice history of the hotel, we are happy we tried it, however, would not come back.