We ate at the hotel restaurant. The bed was comfortable. The room was a nice size and clean. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We valet parked our car and it was taken good care of. We would stay at the Wyndham again.

Liked: We had a nice experience at the hotel.

It's a very old hotel but it is in a fantastic location for Manhattan. The price is exceptional for a NYC hotel and it is a clean, safe place to stay. Rooms were a little small but wouldn't stop me from staying again. Friendly staff.

Liked: Great location; nice price and clean.
Disliked: Small rooms.

Good, old NYC hotel. Great location. Accommodating staff. Safe.

Disliked: Bookkeeping was terrible. It was a father/son trip for us and another father and son. I booked the reservation and said I?d pay for it and the other father and I would settle the finances after the trip. On departure morning, and I realize it was 6:39am, but there was no one at the front desk to print me final bills. I mean no one. But I figured I could call or email back later and get my itemized bills. It wasn?t that easy. After several requests, I received itemized statements. Some of which were our rooms. Some of which were not our rooms and on dates after we left the hotel. It was a mess. It was never resolved. I gave up.

Good location but a tired...

Liked: The location is brilliant and perfect for all of the popular tourist attractions.
Disliked: Unfortunately the hotel is a little tired looking with grubby carpets and curtains. The bath was thick with muck, the windows weren't air tight as we had a freezing cold draft coming through our room and the pillows were approximately the size of a postage stamp.

Superb

Liked: Location was fantastic. Next to the subway and train station not even 1min walk to either. Empire State Building and Maddison square gardens were also opposite.
Disliked: Staff behind the desk were rude both times when we asked when we would receive our room deposit back. Both give me different answers. However the gents by the lifts were very pleasant.

Very poor

Liked: Nothing.
Disliked: It was not clean, the staff was discourteous and indicated not having a better room or being able to clean better.

It was how we expected.

Liked: The view and the location. The staff was very kind.
Disliked: not so clean; it was raining inside the hotel in front of our room; due to its awesome location and history, the hotel deserves a facelift.

Superb

Disliked: Would have liked tea/coffee in room as standard.

Good

Liked: Did not like full size small beds/ bathroom floor was always full of water after someone bathed since drain was the floor. Overall, stay was good and will come again.
Disliked: Bathroom draining system, entire floor was drain for shower.

Great location but small rooms

Liked: Location
Disliked: Rooms were small, no main bar, you could only get a drink from one of the 3 restaurants

Exceptional

Liked: Great location.