The New Yorker A Wyndham Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Joanne G, Massapequa, visiting Madison Square Garden
We ate at the hotel restaurant. The bed was comfortable. The room was a nice size and clean. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We valet parked our car and it was taken good care of. We would stay at the Wyndham again.
Liked: We had a nice experience at the hotel.
Robert G, Toms River
It's a very old hotel but it is in a fantastic location for Manhattan. The price is exceptional for a NYC hotel and it is a clean, safe place to stay. Rooms were a little small but wouldn't stop me from staying again. Friendly staff.
Liked: Great location; nice price and clean.
Disliked: Small rooms.
Arthur Sun, 29 June 2025
Passable
Liked: Location is very central and near the subway.
Disliked: Room is much smaller than the pictures and be aware than queen size bed is 140cm. The keys get demagnetised easily (happened twice for both keys on a 4 nights stay)As well the hotel does not provide free luggages storage service (5usd/pc)
Simonwillgo Sun, 29 June 2025
Retro Hotel in New York...
Liked: Location, Check-in process and check-out - super easy and comfortable room! Retro vibe was awesome, and facilities/transport/attractions near by were many!
Disliked: Hot water took 8-10 minutes to come on, which is a waste of water. Also, many parts of the room and hotel were in disrepair - clean and cleaned regularly, but needed fixing/replacing.
Sandrine Sun, 29 June 2025
Perfect location and view
Liked: The location near the different famous places of New York, the kindness and availability of the staff
Disliked: None
Nikolai Sun, 29 June 2025
Exceptional
Joe Sun, 29 June 2025
Exceptional
Sierra Sun, 29 June 2025
Location was great. The room...
Liked: Location
Disliked: The room was not like it was advertised. The room was way smaller than in the photos. Paying extra for a room with a view was not worth it, the view was just staring into an alley way with a dumpster.
Mandy Sun, 29 June 2025
Better once rooms changed
Liked: Location excellent. Italian restaurant excellent
Disliked: First night, air conditioning banged all night, to turn off, room was stifling. Toilet clogged
Charlene Sun, 29 June 2025
It was a terrible experience
Disliked: Booked a room with view but the room had no view. All night loud music was keeping us awake until 4 AM.
Franco Sun, 29 June 2025
Good
Nitzan Sun, 29 June 2025
Pleasant
Liked: Location
Disliked: Room card