The Hotel @ Fifth Avenue Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Rod, Albuquerque, visiting Madison Square Garden Tue, 5 November 2019
The room was clean and comfortable. The staff was helpful and courteous. The location was just right. We found a gem of a property in Manhattan. We are so looking forward to our next trip to NY.
Disliked: Was not made aware that the breakfast room was closed when booking the reservation.
Abby, Dayton, visiting Irving Plaza Sat, 1 February 2014
The location was perfect, right in the middle of everything! The beds were memory foam and so comfortable! Our room seemed newly remodeled. The room was a bit small but we didn't care - just needed it to sleep and shower! The staff was friendly and helpful. The valet guy could have been a little more friendly but our car got to the parking garage and that's all we needed! The parking garage is right across the street so that was very convenient. We had a great stay!
Liked: Location; very clean; AWESOME beds.
Vikram Fri, 9 May 2025
Pleasant
Liked: LOCATION IS GOOD
Svitlana Fri, 9 May 2025
Superb
Salvatore Thu, 8 May 2025
Good Location in New York
Liked: The location is very central and close to the subway
Disliked: Room was small and the building overall dated
Luigi Sun, 4 May 2025
Pleasant
Liked: Hotel very good position and room size OK for Manhattan
Disliked: Only one lift working, thus waiting forever. We were charged additional 25$ that were not mentioned anywhere. No reaction from management. Still waiting for reimbursement via Booking
Emrecan Sun, 4 May 2025
Good
Illa Sat, 3 May 2025
The best thing about the...
Liked: Location and staff friendly
Disliked: Needs badly updating. Carpets warn out, Infact everything was tackyCould not adjust temperature for shower and just dripping. For the price paid, no complementary water, no shower cap. Sad these little things make a difference. A rip off, really should get a part refund.
Inna Sat, 3 May 2025
Very good
Liked: Everything was good. Great location. Comfortable bed. I'm happy with my stay.
Ian Fri, 2 May 2025
Really enjoyed it, would recommend
Liked: Location great, bed very comfy, hotel staff v helpful when needed, shuttle taxi from airport much appreciated
Disliked: One of the lifts didn't work for much of the time, which meant it took ages getting to or from the floor; toiletries not changed regularly enough
Victoria Thu, 1 May 2025
Overall, hotel is a great...
Liked: Location is very comfortable - you can easily get anywhere. Staff is very kind and helpful, rooms were clean.
Disliked: Can be quite noisy at night, especially if the windows are on the street side
Yael Mon, 28 April 2025
Very good