United States
Canada
United Kingdom
New Zealand
AustraliaThe Gotham Hotel Guest Reviews
Overall Average Score:
Excellent (4.25 out of 5)
Write a review
Menu
Write a review
Hamad Mon, 25 August 2025
Exceptional
Regina Sat, 23 August 2025
Will stay again, good location...
Liked: N/A
Disliked: Pillows
Erica Sat, 23 August 2025
Very good
John Thu, 21 August 2025
Exceptional
Kadi Mon, 18 August 2025
Fun and around plenty of...
Liked: It was a pleasure having someone open the door for us , they were so kind and informative at the front desk. Breakfast was good but wish we could use the 20$ towards that than for the liquor in the room :). Thank you!! Will be back.
Disliked: No, everything was amazing!
Penny Mon, 18 August 2025
Superb
Savannah Mon, 18 August 2025
Great hotel, will stay again
Liked: Staff was very friendly, Brandon checked us in and he was great. The room was super spacious especially for NYC. Very clean, comfortable bed, relatively quiet, strong air conditioning. We enjoyed sitting on the large community balcony in the evening.
Disliked: The blinds weren’t great at blocking out the city lights
Katelyn Fri, 15 August 2025
Had a great time. Friendly,...
Liked: Hotel was beautiful and quiet.
Disliked: Could have used a microwave in the room.
Anna Fri, 15 August 2025
Not bad but not so...
Liked: I don't like to spend a lot of time in public transport during vacation. So location for me is always important and the hotel is located really good for my needs. Also the hotel has public balconies on few top floors with lovely view. The stuff on reception desc is very friendly.
Disliked: Cleaning stuff is definitely lazy (if it's not a hotel rule). They clean the room every day but floor in the room was dusty like a hell. During five days no one checked and refilled coffee capsules and coffee cups. Looks like they just made a bed, change towels and clean the bathroom but nothing else. Room is noisy because of all these technical engines located outside so room's balcony is absolutely useless.
Elizabeth Fri, 15 August 2025
Not worth it
Liked: Location is great, not much else to say about the actual property,very basic for a luxury price.
Disliked: Feels very sterile, tired, sad.My room looked old and had scuffed up walls. Faucets leaked everywhere. Very bland interior decor and the “view and balcony” that I paid for was overlooking a brick wall. It was a disappointment and I will not return to the hotel. Many other better values for a 4 star price.
