The Gotham Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Leeat Sat, 28 June 2025
Great choice
Liked: Great location, large rooms, terrace, friendly staff
Disliked: Charges for early check in and late check out
Carlos Thu, 26 June 2025
Exceptional
Marylu Wed, 25 June 2025
I wish I could gatekeep...
Liked: I truly loved everything about this hotel. The room, location, and customer service. Its all the little things that make staying here worth it!
Disliked: The hallways were always super humid/hot, however that didn't impact our room/stay. We kept our room cold, and it was never impacted by the hallway temp.
Amber Wed, 25 June 2025
Very nice, would stay again
Liked: Location was great. Bed was comfortable. Juliette balcony was very nice, as well as access to higher small outside patios was also a bonus.
Disliked: Surprised there was no smart tv.
Tim Tue, 24 June 2025
Great location and room
Liked: The location was great and walking distance to many main attractions. Also, the rooms size was quite generous for NYC. We also loved the outdoor sitting area on our floor overlooking the front of the building... enjoyed our coffee out there each morning.
Aires Mon, 23 June 2025
It was very good and...
Liked: Location and has their own discounted parking
Disliked: Just the sound that the shower produce when you turn it on. It just makes this loud noise that won’t stop unless you turn it off.
Lynn Mon, 23 June 2025
Exceptional
Katsiaryna Mon, 23 June 2025
Superb
Nancy Sat, 21 June 2025
We had the most amazing...
Liked: The location was perfect! We liked the restaurant on site also. Very safe, clean and the staff was all very nice and professional!!
Disliked: N/A
Joshua Thu, 19 June 2025
I had a great stay.
Liked: Location, room size, staff
Disliked: Wish I could’ve gotten later check out