The Evelyn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Carolyn, Naples, visiting James Beard House Fri, 24 June 2016
The bed was very comfortable, and the bathroom was nice and roomy. Hotel staff was nice; the location is great!
Disliked: No closets! And the noisy renovations to the hotel. Only one elevator working.
Radwa Tue, 29 April 2025
Beautiful, central gem.
Liked: Very central location and very close to subway and bus stations, there’s a Whole Foods close by and a CVS that opens late in case you get the late night munchies! Staff is very friendly and helpful, true to the boutique nature of the hotel. The bakery was very delicious and the room had all the amenities we needed.
Disliked: Would have loved a more generous breakfast (you get one food and one beverage item per person per day) and if the rooms were a tiny bit bigger.
Wilson Tue, 29 April 2025
Other than room, all else...
Disliked: Booking . Com booked me into disability room (I don’t need this). Room was very shabby no place for luggage, no drawers for clothes, no shelves in bathroom for toiletries…..very very disappointed that Evelyn @ 400./nite should have such a room
Kevin Tue, 29 April 2025
Very good stay excellent area...
Nicholas Tue, 29 April 2025
Comfortable room in a great...
Liked: Location and staff. Tasty breakfast
Disliked: Brian toilet. No towels one day.
Jessica Mon, 28 April 2025
Very good
Maria Mon, 28 April 2025
Superb
Liked: Very welcoming, in walking distance to a lot of sights, cosy room
Disliked: Breakfast nit befor 7:00 h and no alternatives. If you have to leave before seven ask them for a coffee machine on your room. They seam to do in auch cases.
Roland Mon, 28 April 2025
Well located and nice hotel...
Liked: Excellent location. Good beds, Nice decor. Simple but good breakfast included.
Disliked: The room (deluxe double double) that we booked was advertised as 36 m2 but was 15 m2 at best and simply too small to accommodate a family of four with luggage. Apparently all of this type of rooms were the same so they are just improperly advertised.
Claudia Sat, 26 April 2025
Nice front desk staff but...
Liked: The restaurant & bar
Disliked: Rooms too small and housekeeping extremely noisy early which is disrespectful
Case Sat, 26 April 2025
Charming hotel in a great...
Liked: Great value. Central location. Breakfast. Tusk Bar.
Disliked: The elevators were slow. The toilet paper was in an odd place in the bathroom.
Adam Fri, 25 April 2025
Superb
0.3 miles from Jazz Standard | |
t6 mins walking |
l |
Steve B "Excellent food and top service from Monji and the team gave us good menu advice and made us feel..." Read Full Review |
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | |
Reserve Online | |
©TripAdvisor 2025 |
0.2 miles from Jazz Standard | |
t4 mins walking |
l |
DarrinSiegfried "Overall terrific experience! Our first time at 57th St. Sanja, our bartender, got the evening off..." Read Full Review |
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | |
Reserve Online | |
©TripAdvisor 2025 |