The Evelyn

The bed was very comfortable, and the bathroom was nice and roomy. Hotel staff was nice; the location is great!

Disliked: No closets! And the noisy renovations to the hotel. Only one elevator working.

Not a 5 star hotel,...

Liked: Great location, if you are interested in NoMAD part, still close to Times Square and all touristy stuff.
Disliked: Super small rooms even by NYC standards. Not the cleanest place (room). If you walked in your socks in the room, they would get dirty in 2 min as probably nobody washed the hardwood floor in ages. The hotel is advertised as 5star, when it fact it is a 4star.

Good location to explore NYC

Liked: Good location, staff very helpful.
Disliked: Small rooms, no wi-fi or television due to outage in that city block, not the hotels fault but very annoying.

Perfectly central little hotel

Liked: Amazing location for a trip to New York. Very central easy walking distance to Empire State Building, plenty of subways stations nearby. Staff were superb offering us water each day, we asked was it possible for a late check out which they organised. Room was very clean and bed was super comfortable. Breakfast was reasonable, nice coffee and pastry which was great for us on the go each morning meaning we had the option to try plenty of brunch places the city has to offer. All in all we would happily stay here again if we were to come back to New York
Disliked: WiFi and tv stopped working for 2 of the 7 days we were there. When talking to staff they explained it was a local area problem due to construction work so not the hotels fault, staff kept us updated in the afternoons when we returned from our day out in the city.

Bad

Very good

Disliked: One of the two elevators was out of order the whole time we were there. Fortunately we were on the 3rd floor so using the stairs was ok.The breakfast was really just a snack, choice of a plain croissant or a small egg sandwich.

Very good

Disliked: One of the elevators was not working the whole time we were there, but fortunately, we were on the 3rd floor and the stairs were convenient.The breakfast was really just a snack.

Superb

Liked: The location was excellent and the bed was very comfortable
Disliked: The elevators were incredibly slow and one was broken down, so there was a lot of waiting around when going and coming to the bedroom, especially because we were on the 12th floor so couldn't use the stairs

Pretty room near Flat Iron-no...

Liked: The room was beautifully decorated, very feminine, cute music motif in the bathroom. The view by the large window was nice. The front desk staff were very friendly.
Disliked: The Wi-Fi was out my entire two night, two day stay. Pretty inconvenient when you have work to do on a laptop in the room. No functioning TV either, no big deal but when you're travelling alone it's nice to have sometimes. It would have been courteous if they'd offered some sort of compensation for the inconvenience, perhaps a refund of the "resort fee" or complimentary mini bar item or something. The bed could have been more comfortable.

Warm staff, great location, beautiful...

Liked: The lovely staff made us feel very welcome. They were very attentive to our needs and gave our stay a personal touch.
Disliked: -