Convenient, reasonably priced hotel for...

Liked: Breakfast was much better than the average chain hotel. The bed was super comfy. The room was a decent size for NYC. Liked the location directly across from new Moynihan train station, and half a block from 8th Ave where it was easy to get a taxi. Check in very slow and had to push to get a room at 3:45, 15 min before allowable check in time. Desk Mgr finally stepped in and got us a room. Did not use room clean-up staff except to get fresh towels from them. Liked walk-in shower.
Disliked: Check in.... friendlier and more accommodating. Shower water pressure could be better.

Very good location if you...

Liked: Location
Disliked: shower

Superb

Exceptional

great location, comfortable hotel

Liked: location, comfortable bed, overall good experience
Disliked: Water pressure in the shower could be better. breakfast is very basic and offers disposable cutlery and plates which is unacceptable

excellent

Liked: close to Maddison square garden?s
Disliked: bar very expensive

disappointing, definitely did not meet...

Liked: location was suitable
Disliked: old furniture, poor status of bathroom, no any view from the room (looked over the big wall from another building, there were no daily light or sun

Pleasant

Will stay again.

Liked: This hotel is in a fantastic location. Penn Station is across the road and you can pretty much everywhere in NYC by subway from here. The ACE train stop is particularly convenient and is ideal for trips to Broadway. The included breakfast is decent and plentiful and ideal for saving some money and keeping your energy up for a busy day. The rooftop bar is an added bonus and has great views of Manhattan. Rooms are clean and comfortable too.
Disliked: Elevators can be particularly busy at times, especially with public access to the rooftop bar and there can be a small wait occasionally. When the temperature dropped, the AC started automatically blowing out hot air, which meant I had to switch it off and open the window, as I like a cold room to sleep in, but this is a personal preference.