Liked: Location & Staff
Disliked: Only king beds available. Good thing we're close friends, else the sleeping situation would've been awkward. Also, room could've used an armchair.

Liked: Excellent stay at the hotel.
Disliked: They don't tell you that you have to pay for parking. I took my car to the place across the street where they told me to park and they guy just asked me if I was staying at a hotel and so I said yes. Next morning I was charged $54 for 10hours! Ridiculous

Liked: Room had a good central location and friendly check-in staff. It was very clean and met the bill of what I needed in NYC very well. I didn't plan to spend much time inside the place and it was perfect for that.
Disliked: Insulation between room and corridor is not great - if you are planning on sleeping in, consider earplugs.

Liked: The view.
Disliked: Room way to small for the price.

Liked: I like the comfy beds and cookies
Disliked: No adult film channels on TV

Liked: Location and price were great, and it was a short walk to the metro.
Disliked: They had signs for breakfast, and all hotels I've seen that do this have it included. It was not. When we walked into the buffet, there was no one there to tell us otherwise. The employee only came after we had eaten, then forced us to pay $50 + tip..

Liked: Close to Penn Station
Disliked: Probably closer to a two star hotel. Needs renovation. Does not seem like a Hilton property. Dingy and overpriced. Not a good value.

Liked: The location of the hotel is good - right near NY Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. There isn't much near it on 29th Street, but lots of good stuff to eat and do on the neighboring 6th and 7th Aves. Hotel room was small, but that's normal for NYC.
Disliked: elevators were slow and the room smelled like air freshener since someone had put them in the vents.

Liked: Free cookies
Disliked: The rooms were small.