Fabulous

Liked: Lovely hotel in a a great area. Fabulous breakfast included

well located hotel and comfortable...

Liked: Perfectly located, calm and well decorated. Very comfortable bed. A la carte breakfast included in room rate was good.
Disliked: As expected, room was small. Beware if you leave your receipts at breakfast empty: we realized at check out that waiters had been giving themselves tips for breakfast without our consent !!

Good

Liked: Breakfast was great. Bed comfortable and warm - liked "fur" throw
Disliked: Would have liked a price list in room for beverages and snacks. Ordered drinks from waiter in lobby and 20 minutes later was told they didn't have what we ordered - lobby and bar area was not crowded, why did it take him so long to tell us?

Good

Liked: Breakfast was great.Bed comfortable and warm - liked "fur" throw
Disliked: Would have liked a price list in room for beverages and snacks.Ordered drinks from waiter in lobby and 20 minutes later was told they didn't have what we ordered - lobby and bar area was not crowded, why did it take him so long to tell us?

We enjoyed our stay here....

Liked: We loved the area and close walking distance to West Village Restaurants- close to Train station to Uptown. Loved the Hotel -the staff were very friendly and helpful. The beds were very comfortable.
Disliked: Cannot think of anything! It is a bit costly.

We enjoyed our stay here. Loved being in the Village.

Liked: We loved the area and close walking distance to West Village Restaurants- close to Train station to Uptown. Loved the Hotel -the staff were very friendly and helpful. The beds were very comfortable.
Disliked: Cannot think of anything! It is a bit costly.

Good

Liked: Great staff
Disliked: Room is very small

Good

Liked: Great staff
Disliked: Room is very small

A very comfortable stay in a classic NYC hotel right off Washington Square Park

Liked: The Marlton is a classic New York hotel in an excellent location. The staff were very friendly, the bed was super comfortable, and the breakfast was quite nice. The rooms were very very quiet and we slept perfectly each night. Ive stayed in other hotels and apartments in NYC and this certainly was not the case there. Also the temperature control in the room was top notch. One other noteworthy experience was the breakfast every morning. We always easily got a table right away and the servers were attentive.
Disliked: There are trade offs to consider when staying in a classic traditional hotel, where the facilities are on the older side. The rooms are very small with limited space to move around or spread out. There certainly was nowhere to work in the room (ie desk). However, the lobby is quite spacious and comfortable and I saw several people working there. The water pressure in the shower was on the lower side and the faucets were traditional with the hot and cold settings as separate dials. That said, these things did not put me off the hotel and I would certainly stay there again in the future.