4.8 Exceptional Based on 142 Reviews

Reserve Online

Fifth Season

Our Pick: Top Rated ($31-$50)

34 East Broadway, Port Jefferson (Map)

Contemporary American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

279 Reviews

v0.3 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.6 Wonderful Based on 110 Reviews

Reserve Online

Pasta Pasta

234 East Main Street, Port Jefferson (Map)

Contemporary Italian

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

272 Reviews

v0.1 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 80 Reviews

Reserve Online

Bliss Restaurant

Our Pick: Top Rated ($30 and under)

766 Route 25A, East Setauket (Map)

American

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

115 Reviews

v2.9 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 242 Reviews

Reserve Online

Ragazzi Italian Kitchen & Bar

2950 Middle Country Road, Nesconset (Map)

Italian

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

204 Reviews

v6.6 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.9 Exceptional Based on 247 Reviews

Reserve Online

Vintage Prime Steakhouse

433 North Country Road, Saint James (Map)

Steakhouse

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

32 Reviews

v7.0 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 147 Reviews

Reserve Online

Spiro's

4 Patchogue Drive, Rocky Point (Map)

Steakhouse

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

213 Reviews

v5.9 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

5.0 Exceptional Based on 1 Review

Reserve Online

Alexandros Restaurant

1060 Route 25A, Mount Sinai (Map)

Mediterranean

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

74 Reviews

v3.5 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 18 Reviews

Reserve Online

Bahama Breeze - Lake Grove

612 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove (Map)

Caribbean

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

178 Reviews

v6.6 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.9 Exceptional Based on 302 Reviews

Reserve Online

Osteria Umbra

197 Terry Rd, Smithtown (Map)

Italian

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

41 Reviews

v8.7 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

3.5 Good Based on 2 Reviews

Reserve Online

Seaport Diner

5045 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station (Map)

American

lGood

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

78 Reviews

v1.7 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.4 Excellent Based on 198 Reviews

Reserve Online

The Stone Goat

552 N Country Rd, Saint James (Map)

American

lExcellent

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

v6.0 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve

4.5 Wonderful Based on 79 Reviews

Reserve Online

PJ Lobster House

134 Main Street, Port Jefferson (Map)

Seafood

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

v2.1 miles from Theatre Three Port Jefferson

Reserve