4.8 Exceptional Based on 78 Reviews

Reserve Online

Vine Street Cafe

Our Pick: Top Rated ($30 and under)

41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island (Map)

American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

247 Reviews

v4.4 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.6 Wonderful Based on 22 Reviews

Reserve Online

Il Capuccino Ristorante

30 Madison St, Sag Harbor (Map)

Italian

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

197 Reviews

v0.3 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 11 Reviews

Reserve Online

K Pasa

2 Main St, Sag Harbor (Map)

Tapas / Small Plates

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

16 Reviews

v< 0.1 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 19 Reviews

Reserve Online

Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor

6 Bay St., Sag Harbor (Map)

Italian

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

49 Reviews

v0.1 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 46 Reviews

Reserve Online

Noah's

Our Pick: Top Rated ($31-$50)

136 Front Street, Greenport (Map)

Tapas / Small Plates

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

677 Reviews

v7.7 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 26 Reviews

Reserve Online

M.J. Dowling's

3360 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor (Map)

American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

47 Reviews

v2.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.9 Exceptional Based on 58 Reviews

Reserve Online

Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant

2266 Main Street, Bridgehampton (Map)

French American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

18 Reviews

v4.7 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 23 Reviews

Reserve Online

The Restaurant at Baron's Cove

31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor (Map)

American

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

v0.3 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.9 Exceptional Based on 74 Reviews

Reserve Online

Elaia Estiatorio

95 School St, Bridgehampton (Map)

Greek

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

33 Reviews

v4.7 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.9 Exceptional Based on 111 Reviews

Reserve Online

Bistro Ete

760 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill (Map)

French

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

32 Reviews

v6.9 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 42 Reviews

Reserve Online

Cove Hollow Tavern

85 Montauk Hwy, East Hampton (Map)

American

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

17 Reviews

v5.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 16 Reviews

Reserve Online

Dopo il Ponte

2402 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton (Map)

Italian

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

7 Reviews

v4.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Reserve