Umberto's of New Hyde Park - Original

Old-School Italian Flavor Just Minutes from the Stage

Umberto's of New Hyde Park – Original is a classic, family-run Italian restaurant with a warm, welcoming vibe and a reputation for hearty portions and traditional recipes. Located on Jericho Turnpike in New Hyde Park, it’s a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike looking for comfort food in a bustling, casual setting. With its old-world charm, wood-accented interiors, and bustling pizzeria in front, Umberto’s offers both a sit-down dining experience and quick bites for those on the go.

Why Concert-goers love it

Just a quick drive from several popular Long Island music venues, Umberto’s is ideal for a pre-show bite or casual post-concert gathering. The restaurant is known for its efficient service and ability to handle groups, meaning you won’t be rushed but won’t miss your show either. The front pizzeria is perfect for grabbing a slice if you're in a hurry, while the dining room offers a more relaxed space to fuel up before the music starts. The overall vibe is lively, but not too noisy—making it a great place to get pumped for the night ahead.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends sharing classic pies and pasta before the show
• Solo travelers grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a laid-back dinner
• Couples looking for a cozy, low-key Italian meal
• Fans wanting a lively pre-show space with good energy and hearty food
• Budget-conscious music fans who want generous portions at fair prices

What People Say

Reviewers consistently praise Umberto’s for its legendary pizza—especially their Sicilian slices and signature Grandma pie. The pasta dishes and chicken parm also get high marks for flavor and portion size. Guests love the friendly, fast service and the nostalgic atmosphere that makes it feel like a neighborhood staple. Many say it’s their go-to spot before heading out for a show or event nearby.

Areas for Improvement

The restaurant can get quite busy on weekends, especially around dinner rush, so expect a wait if you don’t have a reservation. Parking in the area can also be a bit tight, especially on concert nights—arrive early if you can. Some note the decor is a bit dated, but that’s part of its classic charm.

The Bottom Line

If you're craving old-school Italian comfort food in a lively, convenient spot before a concert, Umberto’s is a tried-and-true favorite you can count on.