The Old Mill

Name: The Old Mill
Address: 5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY

The Old Mill, 5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck

| / Venues / New York State Venues

Enter Your Date/Time

4.6

RESTAURANT RATING:

WONDERFUL

4.6 out of 5 (116 Ratings)

1.4 miles Martha Clara Vineyards

Average Price

$31 to $50

Cuisine

American

Opening Hours

Mon, Wed-Sun 4:00 pm-11:00 pm
Sat, Sun 12:00 pm-3:00 pm

The Old Mill Customer Reviews

Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of The Old Mill?

Write a review

The Old Mill is #17 of 40 things to do in Mattituck

4 out of 5

By: Clivanos

Tue 15 Jul, 2025

l	Great vibe and great view. Food was delicious . Loved the grilled squid appetizer and tuna tartare and the oysters were fresh and delicious. Service was friendly and attentive. Will be eating there... Read Full Review

5 out of 5

By: S O

Sat 28 Jun, 2025

l	This newly reopened restaurant is a fabulous addition to the growing number of restaurants in the area. Owners Anthony & Angela make it so welcoming along with their excellent wines and staff. I... Read Full Review

5 out of 5

By: DesertByrd, Bisbee, Arizona

Sat 28 Jun, 2025

l	Exceptional food, customer service, and building had been completely renovated, too! Our server was Brandon - very professional, helpful, and patient with our 96 yr old parent. Tess, the manager... Read Full Review