THE HARTLEY

Modern American Comfort Just Steps from Madison’s Music Scene

Located in the heart of Madison, NJ, The Hartley offers a refined yet relaxed American dining experience just minutes from local concert venues. With its warm, welcoming atmosphere and upscale comfort food, The Hartley blends neighborhood charm with a touch of sophistication. Housed in a beautifully restored space on Greenwood Avenue, it’s a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike looking for a cozy pre-show meal or a nightcap after the encore.

Why Concert-goers love it

Proximity is key—the Hartley is just a short walk or drive from Madison’s top music venues, making it an ideal pre-show stop. Guests love the efficient service that gets you in and out on time for your setlist, and the ambiance is lively without being too loud—perfect for conversation before the show. While there's no official pre-show menu, the well-curated selection of small plates and mains suits both quick bites and leisurely dinners.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends heading to a concert and craving sharable plates
• Solo travelers looking to enjoy a quality meal at the bar
• Couples planning a romantic night out with music and great food
• Fans wanting a lively but intimate space to fuel up before the show
• Budget-conscious music lovers looking for quality food at fair prices

What People Say

Reviewers on OpenTable and TripAdvisor consistently praise The Hartley’s seasonal menu, cocktail program, and attentive staff. Locals call it “a gem in Madison” and rave about favorites like the braised short ribs and truffle fries. Guests also highlight the cozy decor and thoughtful wine list, noting it’s a great spot to start or end an evening out.

Areas for Improvement

Some diners mention that the space can feel a bit tight during peak hours, and reservations are recommended, especially on concert nights. While the menu is well-executed, a few reviewers wished for more vegetarian options.

The Bottom Line

With its inviting vibe, great food, and convenient location, The Hartley is a top pick for concert-goers looking to elevate their night with a delicious American meal.