Name: The Brooklyn Diner Times Square
Address: 155 West 43rd Street, New York, NY
Rating: 4.75

All-American Comfort Steps from the Stage

Located in the heart of Manhattan, just off Times Square, Brooklyn Diner Times Square brings a nostalgic New York vibe with a modern twist. Think gleaming booths, neon signs, and a menu packed with comforting American favorites. It's the kind of place where you can grab a towering pastrami sandwich, a slice of cheesecake the size of your head, or an all-day breakfast before heading to your show.

Despite its name, this is no greasy spoon. The Brooklyn Diner is known for its high-quality ingredients, generous portions, and a polished yet relaxed atmosphere that makes it a standout spot in the bustling theater and entertainment district.

Why Concert-goers love it

Its prime location just a few blocks from major music venues like Radio City Music Hall and Madison Square Garden makes it an easy meet-up point before a show. The service is quick and friendly, which is ideal if you're short on time. Plus, the vibe is lively without being too loud—perfect for getting pumped up before a concert. Open late and with a full bar, it’s also a great post-show stop.

Who this Restaurant is great for

Groups of friends looking to share giant plates of nachos and milkshakes

Solo travelers grabbing a burger at the counter before doors open

Couples enjoying a retro-diner date night before the big show

Fans who want an energetic pre-show hangout spot

Budget-conscious music fans who appreciate big portions for the price

What People Say

Reviewers love the classic diner ambiance and say it “feels like old-school New York with a touch of Broadway glamour.” The matzo ball soup and chicken pot pie get rave reviews, and the friendly staff are often mentioned as a highlight. Many say it’s their go-to pre-show dinner spot, thanks to the quick turnaround and central location.

Areas for Improvement

It’s a bit on the pricey side for a diner, especially given the location, and it can get crowded before showtime—so consider making a reservation or arriving a bit early. Also, while the menu is broad, vegetarians may find fewer options than expected.

The Bottom Line

Brooklyn Diner Times Square is a fun, fast, and flavorful stop for concert-goers who want a true taste of classic New York before the music begins.

The Brooklyn Diner Times Square Customer Reviews

Overall Average Score:

Exceptional (4.7 out of 5)

Write a review

Go. Eat. Enjoy. And like shampoo (lather, rinse, repeat), go again (at THIS location).

Liked: Fast service, terrific food, generous portions, and a pleasant environment.
Disliked: I was so pleased I decided to visit the location on 57th Street, which is closed for remodeling. Yeah, there's a wannabe alternative around the corner, but save your time (astoundingly slow service).

Make sure you go there - food was excellent. Very clean. Let them know ahead of time if you are going to a play and need to be out; book on OpenTable.

Liked: Food; location to theatre; friendliness; using OpenTable.
Disliked: Service was a tad slow, but it was busy and lunch time. But they were great in getting us out on time for the play so it was great!

Liked: Service was excellent - somehow the waitress found out it was our anniversary and brought out two glasses of champagne. Food was very good - must order the chicken pot pie.
Disliked: None.

The restaurant was costly but they have very good food! We had chicken pot pies, which were delicious and very filling! The veggie burger was also very good.

Disliked: The prices were expensive. A small bowl of chicken sour - $12.50. Give me a break. I don' t have to pay their rent!