Ted's Montana Grill - NYC

All-American Flavor Just Steps from the Stage

Ted's Montana Grill in NYC brings a warm, Western-inspired twist to classic American cuisine, right in the heart of Midtown Manhattan. Located on West 51st Street inside the Time Life Building, it’s a cozy, rustic-style restaurant with leather booths, wood-paneled walls, and a friendly, laid-back atmosphere that feels like a welcome escape from the city’s buzz—without leaving it.

Known for its commitment to sustainability and fresh ingredients, Ted’s offers a hearty menu featuring everything from bison burgers and hand-cut steaks to comfort food favorites and seasonal cocktails. It’s a great pick for anyone looking to fuel up before catching a show nearby.

Why Concert-goers love it

This spot is just a short walk from some of the city’s biggest concert venues, making it an ideal pre-show stop. Service is notably fast and attentive, so you won’t be rushed but also won’t miss your performance. The atmosphere is lively without being too loud, perfect for chatting about setlists or grabbing a drink before the lights go down. The menu offers plenty of filling options to keep you energized through the encore.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a casual, satisfying dinner spot
• Solo travelers who want a comfortable place to relax and eat at the bar
• Couples enjoying a romantic weekend and a quality meal
• Fans wanting to soak up some pre-show energy in a fun setting
• Budget-conscious concert-goers seeking good value and generous portions

What People Say

Guests love the friendly service and the consistently well-prepared dishes, especially the bison burgers, pot roast, and fresh salads. Many say it’s a go-to place for a reliable and relaxing meal before a show. The comfortable booth seating and inviting bar area also get high marks for ambiance. Reviewers on TripAdvisor and OpenTable frequently praise the cleanliness, helpful staff, and welcoming vibe.

Areas for Improvement

While the menu is a crowd-pleaser, some diners mention that prices are a bit high for casual fare—but most agree the quality and portions justify it. It can also get busy during peak hours, so a reservation is a smart move if you're on a tight pre-show schedule.

The Bottom Line

If you're craving a hearty, all-American meal in a comfortable setting just minutes from Midtown’s top concerts, Ted’s Montana Grill is a solid—and satisfying—choice.