Speakeasy, Die Softly: Immersive Murder Mystery at Carmine's

Step Into a Delicious Mystery Before the Show

Speakeasy, Die Softly at Carmine’s is not your average dinner out—this is an immersive murder mystery experience set inside one of Times Square’s most beloved Italian restaurants. Nestled just steps away from Broadway theaters and major music venues, it combines hearty Italian classics with 1920s flair, live-action intrigue, and a whole lot of fun. Think moody lighting, flapper-era vibes, and oversized pasta platters served family-style in true Carmine’s tradition.

Why Concert-goers love it

Located just a short walk from some of the city's biggest stages, Speakeasy, Die Softly is ideal for concert-goers looking to turn dinner into part of the night out. With shows wrapping up in time for evening performances, it’s a great pre-show pick. The immersive format keeps things exciting without being too long, and the shared-plate dining means quick service and no waiting around for individual orders—perfect if you're watching the clock.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends who want dinner and entertainment all in one
• Solo travelers looking for something unique and social
• Couples on a romantic, themed night out
• Fans who want a festive, high-energy vibe before the concert
• Budget-conscious music fans—the portions are huge and shareable

What People Say

Reviewers love the “fun, interactive storyline” and “excellent performances” from the cast, calling it a “blast from start to finish.” Many mention the “generous portions” of classic Italian dishes and appreciate that it’s a “great value for a full evening of food and entertainment.” The ambiance is frequently praised as “immersive and lively,” with guests raving about the 1920s decor and festive atmosphere.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests mention that the space can get a bit loud—though that’s often part of the fun. Also, if you’re looking for a quiet, intimate dinner, this may not be your best bet. Seating can be close together due to the family-style setup, so it’s more about community than privacy.

The Bottom Line

If you’re looking to kick off your concert night with great food, a touch of drama, and a lot of laughs, Speakeasy, Die Softly at Carmine’s delivers a truly memorable pre-show experience.