Sicily

Authentic Italian Flavors in the Heart of the Theater District

Just a short walk from the bustling energy of Times Square and iconic NYC music venues, Sicily offers a cozy escape with authentic Italian charm. Tucked along Restaurant Row on W 46th Street, this intimate spot delivers a warm, trattoria-style atmosphere with a focus on fresh, Sicilian-inspired dishes. With its candlelit tables, rustic decor, and friendly service, it’s an ideal place to unwind before the show starts or celebrate after the encore.

Why Concert-goers love it

Location is everything, and Sicily nails it—just minutes from major Broadway theaters and music venues, making it a go-to for pre-show dinners. The staff is known for its efficient, attentive service, helping you make it to curtain time without stress. The atmosphere offers a peaceful contrast to the buzz outside, with a noise level that’s low enough for conversation but lively enough to get you in the mood for a night out. There’s no official pre-show menu, but the well-curated selection of pastas, seafood, and Sicilian wines makes for a satisfying start to any concert evening.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends grabbing dinner before a big night
• Solo travelers looking for a quality meal in a welcoming setting
• Couples planning a romantic evening with music and fine food
• Fans who want a lively yet relaxed atmosphere before the show
• Budget-conscious travelers who still want a satisfying, sit-down meal

What People Say

Diners rave about the homemade pastas, especially the lasagna and seafood linguine, calling them “authentic” and “packed with flavor.” Reviewers on TripAdvisor and OpenTable frequently mention the warm, welcoming staff and the restaurant’s ability to accommodate last-minute pre-show reservations. Many also highlight the intimate ambiance as a major plus, saying it feels like “a little piece of Italy in the middle of Manhattan.”

Areas for Improvement

The space is on the smaller side, so it can feel a bit tight during peak hours—booking ahead is a must. Some guests noted that while the menu is delicious, it’s not extensive, so picky eaters might have limited options. And if you’re in a rush, let your server know—service is friendly, but can lean leisurely unless prompted.

The Bottom Line

If you’re heading to a concert and want a delicious, relaxed Italian meal just steps from the action, Sicily is a charming and convenient choice.