Scarr's Pizza

Old-School Pizza Perfection in the Heart of the Lower East Side

Scarr's Pizza brings serious retro charm and some of the best New York-style slices to the bustling Lower East Side. Set in a narrow, neon-lit space on Orchard Street, this beloved local spot combines vintage 70s-style decor with a modern commitment to quality. The dough is milled in-house, the cheese is top-tier, and the sauce hits just right—no frills, just incredible pizza.

Whether you're grabbing a quick bite before a show or looking to soak in the neighborhood's cool energy, Scarr's keeps things casual, fast, and delicious.

Why Concert-goers love it

Scarr's is just a short walk from some of the Lower East Side’s most popular live music venues, making it an easy stop for a pre-show meal. The service is speedy—perfect when you’re on the clock—and the vibe is loud enough to feel energized but not overwhelming. It’s the kind of place where you can be in and out in 20 minutes or hang around with friends over a beer and a second slice.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a laid-back, wallet-friendly bite
• Solo travelers who want a quick, quintessential NYC food experience
• Couples craving comfort food before a night out
• Fans who want a lively, local feel before the show
• Budget-conscious music lovers who don’t want to compromise on flavor

What People Say

Reviewers love the crispy-yet-chewy crust, the fresh ingredients, and the fact that it feels like a throwback in the best possible way. Many note that the pepperoni slice is a must-try, and the no-nonsense service makes it ideal for concert-goers on a schedule. The small bar in the back also gets praise for its cool, understated vibe.

Areas for Improvement

Seating is limited and the narrow space can get crowded during peak hours—so be prepared to stand or take your slice to go. Also, there's often a line, but it moves quickly and is usually worth the wait.

The Bottom Line

Scarr's Pizza is a fast, flavorful, and iconic stop for anyone heading to a Lower East Side concert—classic NYC vibes included.