Sardi's Customer Reviews
Write a review
A true New York institution, Sardi's sits in the heart of the Theatre District on West 44th Street, just a short stroll from many of the city's top concert and performance venues. Known for its old-school charm and iconic caricature-covered walls, this continental cuisine spot blends timeless elegance with a casual vibe. It's the kind of place where Broadway legends dined—and where music lovers still gather before a show.
Location is everything for concert-goers, and Sardi's delivers. It's just around the corner from major venues, making it ideal for a quick bite or leisurely meal before the music starts. The menu is classic and crowd-pleasing, with options like shrimp cocktail, Chicken Sardi’s, and hearty pastas. Service is known for being prompt and friendly—perfect when you’re on a schedule. The atmosphere is energetic but not too loud, offering a relaxed spot to fuel up and soak in the Broadway buzz.
Guests rave about the nostalgic ambiance, calling it a true “slice of Broadway history.” Many appreciate the efficient service that gets you in and out on time for curtain call. Others mention the consistent food quality and generous portions, with the crab cakes and French onion soup earning special praise. Diners love soaking in the walls lined with celebrity caricatures, adding to the excitement of a night out in NYC.
Some reviewers note that the menu may feel a bit dated or traditional, especially for those seeking trendier fare. Prices can be on the higher side, but many say it's worth it for the experience. On busy nights, tables can feel a bit close together—but that’s part of the Broadway hustle and charm.
With its unbeatable location, classic menu, and showbiz atmosphere, Sardi's is a top pick for concert-goers looking to dine in true New York style before the lights go down.
Write a review
Gail, Walla Walla, Washington Thu, 27 February 2025
We were seated at our reserved time that gave us 2-1/2 hours to wait until the theater opened. Our server gave us all the time we needed, for which I was grateful. The food was delicious and well presented. I especially appreciated them storing my doggy bag for pick up after the show. Very accommodating and respectful staff.
Liked: The ambiance and staff.
Disliked: Nothing.
Sandra, Scottsdale
Our 2nd visit in two weeks. The first time was at the bar for drinks before a performance and dinner last night before the theatre. Great service, food and love the atmosphere! We'll definitely be back a few more times before we return home at the end of the month.
Liked: The service and the food were top notch. Perfect location to the theatres. Loved all the caricatures!
Disliked: Nothing.
Marilyn R, Dover MA
Very pleasant; attentive waiters; good food.
Liked: Food very good.
Disliked: Nothing.
Sardi's Restaurant is #611 of 14718 things to do in New York City
By: Chris S | |||
Thu 5 Jun, 2025 | |||
|
By: Petra M, Granbury, Texas | |||
Fri 30 May, 2025 | |||
|
By: PJinNorthBend, North Bend, Washington | |||
Thu 29 May, 2025 | |||
|