San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar

Authentic Italian Flavors Just Minutes from the Music

San Matteo Italian Restaurant & Bar is a warm, welcoming spot in Fort Myers serving contemporary Italian cuisine in an upscale-casual setting. Located in the charming Village Center, it’s just a short drive from many of the area’s popular concert venues, making it an ideal pre-show dining destination. With its cozy interior, attentive service, and a menu full of homemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and Italian wines, San Matteo blends classic flavors with a modern touch.

Why Concert-goers love it

This restaurant is a favorite among concert-goers thanks to its fast, friendly service and easy-to-navigate menu—great when you're watching the clock before a show. Guests consistently mention that food comes out promptly, and the laid-back vibe makes it easy to relax without feeling rushed. Plus, the location allows you to grab a meal without straying far from your evening entertainment plans.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to split a few pizzas and share a bottle of wine
• Solo travelers who want a comforting meal at the bar before heading to a show
• Couples planning a romantic concert weekend
• Fans wanting a lively, yet relaxed pre-show space
• Budget-conscious music fans who still want quality Italian eats

What People Say

Reviews on TripAdvisor and OpenTable highlight the authentic flavors and generous portions. Diners love the homemade pasta dishes, especially the carbonara and bolognese, and many mention the wood-fired pizzas as a must-try. The service is consistently praised for being attentive and efficient, a major plus for those on a concert schedule. Guests also appreciate the wine selection and cozy ambiance, which feels both upscale and approachable.

Areas for Improvement

Some reviewers note that the restaurant can get a bit busy during peak hours, which might mean a short wait if you don’t have a reservation. Others mention that parking in the center can be limited on weekends, so give yourself a few extra minutes to find a spot.

The Bottom Line

If you're looking for a reliable, delicious, and conveniently located Italian meal before a concert, San Matteo is a smart—and satisfying—choice.