Papi Pasta & Pizza

Classic Italian Comfort Just Steps from the Action

Papi Pasta & Pizza is a laid-back, no-fuss Italian spot nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan. Just around the corner from major concert venues and Penn Station, it’s a casual go-to for anyone craving hearty pasta, fresh pizza, and fast service before or after a show. The vibe is relaxed and welcoming, with counter-service efficiency and plenty of seating for small groups or solo diners on the go.

Why Concert-goers love it

Located just a short walk from Madison Square Garden and other popular music venues, Papi Pasta & Pizza is a favorite for its super quick service and generous portions. You can grab a slice, a pasta bowl, or a fresh salad and be in and out in time for doors. It’s also open late, making it perfect for a post-concert bite. The casual setup means no reservations needed — just walk in, eat, and go.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a quick, shared meal before the show
• Solo travelers who want something tasty without the wait
• Couples keeping things casual before a big night out
• Fans who want a fun, busy vibe to get hyped before the concert
• Budget-conscious music lovers who don’t want to splurge on dinner

What People Say

Reviews on TripAdvisor and OpenTable praise the friendly staff, value for money, and surprisingly authentic flavors for a fast-casual spot. Diners love the large portion sizes, especially the creamy Alfredo pasta and crispy-thin pizza slices. Many also mention it’s an ideal place for a quick bite without sacrificing quality or taste.

Areas for Improvement

This isn’t the place for a long, lingering dinner — seating is basic, and the atmosphere can be a bit hectic during peak hours. Some guests have noted that it’s more of a grab-and-go or casual dine-in spot than a traditional sit-down restaurant. And while most dishes are crowd-pleasers, don’t expect high-end culinary flair.

The Bottom Line

If you're catching a show nearby and want fast, filling Italian food without the fuss, Papi Pasta & Pizza hits the spot.