O'Donoghue's Bar & Restaurant

Comfort Food and Cold Pints in the Heart of NYC

O'Donoghue's Bar & Restaurant is a classic Irish pub located on West 44th Street, just a short walk from Times Square and some of New York City's biggest concert venues. With its warm wood interiors, friendly staff, and a menu full of satisfying Irish and American favorites, this casual spot is perfect for fueling up before a show or winding down after one. Whether you're craving a Guinness and shepherd’s pie or just looking for a laid-back place to gather, O'Donoghue's hits the right notes.

Why Concert-goers love it

Its unbeatable location—mere minutes from Broadway theaters and live music spots—makes O'Donoghue's a top pick for pre-show meetups. The vibe is lively but not overwhelming, so you can easily have a conversation over drinks. Many reviewers highlight the quick and friendly service, which means no stress getting in and out before curtain call. Plus, the pub-style menu is hearty and filling, great for lining your stomach before a night of singing along to your favorite band.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a fun and social pre-show meal
• Solo travelers catching a bucket-list performance and wanting a friendly bar atmosphere
• Couples on a romantic weekend in NYC who want comfort food in a cozy setting
• Fans who love a lively, music-loving crowd before a big concert
• Budget-conscious music lovers seeking good value near Times Square

What People Say

Guests consistently rave about the authentic Irish pub feel and the welcoming staff. Many mention the generous portions and flavorful dishes like fish and chips, burgers, and Irish stew. The selection of beers and whiskeys is another highlight, especially for those wanting to start the night with a proper pint. Visitors also appreciate that despite being so close to tourist hotspots, O'Donoghue's still feels genuine and down-to-earth.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests note that the pub can get quite busy before showtime, so service might slow down slightly during peak hours. And while the ambiance is classic and cozy, those seeking a high-end dining experience may find it more casual than expected. Still, for most concert-goers, that’s part of the charm.

The Bottom Line

For a relaxed, satisfying meal just steps from NYC’s top concert venues, O'Donoghue's offers a winning mix of location, atmosphere, and classic Irish hospitality.