Mermaid Inn Upper West Side

Seafood and City Vibes Just Steps from the Stage

The Mermaid Inn Upper West Side is a relaxed, stylish seafood spot nestled on Columbus Avenue, just a short walk from some of New York City's most iconic concert venues. With its cozy East Coast charm, warm lighting, and casual yet polished ambiance, it’s a favorite for locals and travelers alike looking to enjoy fresh oysters, lobster rolls, and an excellent raw bar before heading out for a night of music.

Why Concert-goers love it

Located just blocks from top cultural and music venues, the Mermaid Inn is ideal for a pre-show bite. Quick, friendly service means you won't be stressing about making your curtain time, and the noise level stays pleasantly buzzy without being overwhelming—so you can still chat about the setlist. Happy hour deals on oysters and wine are a big draw, and the laid-back atmosphere makes it easy to drop in without dressing up.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a fun, shareable seafood spread
• Solo travelers who want a welcoming bar and good conversation
• Couples planning a romantic concert night out
• Fans who want an upbeat, social spot to grab a bite before the show
• Budget-conscious concert-goers looking for great happy hour value

What People Say

Reviews consistently praise the Mermaid Inn for its super-fresh seafood, especially the oysters and lobster rolls. Diners love the relaxed yet polished vibe, attentive staff, and the complimentary chocolate pudding or fortune-telling fish offered at the end of the meal. Many say it’s their go-to spot before events at nearby theaters and concert halls, thanks to the reliable timing and quality.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests mention that the space can feel a bit tight during peak hours, so reservations are a smart move. The menu leans seafood-heavy (as you'd expect), so picky eaters or non-seafood fans might find fewer options.

The Bottom Line

Mermaid Inn Upper West Side is a delicious, dependable seafood stop with great energy and speedy service—perfect for fueling up before the music starts.