Medium Rare - New York

Classic Steakhouse Vibes Just Steps from the Action

Medium Rare – New York brings a Parisian twist to the American steakhouse, offering a straightforward menu and a cozy bistro feel in Manhattan’s Murray Hill. Just a short ride from some of NYC’s biggest music venues, this spot is known for its signature prix fixe menu: tender steak, crispy hand-cut fries, and their house-made secret sauce, served in two rounds for ultimate satisfaction. The vibe is warm, casual, and just upscale enough to feel special without overdoing it.

Why Concert-goers love it

If you’re heading to a show and want to fuel up without wasting time flipping through a huge menu, Medium Rare keeps it simple and efficient. The prix fixe format means food comes out fast, and the restaurant’s streamlined service is ideal for those on a tight concert schedule. Located just a few subway stops from major Midtown venues, it’s a convenient and crowd-pleasing pre-show stop. Plus, the lively but not-too-loud atmosphere makes it easy to chat before the music starts.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a no-fuss, satisfying meal before the show
• Solo travelers wanting a quick, quality bite before heading out
• Couples enjoying a romantic night out with a concert twist
• Fans who love a good steak and a buzzing pre-show vibe
• Budget-conscious diners—prix fixe pricing makes things simple and fair

What People Say

Reviewers consistently praise the value-for-money prix fixe menu and the rich, flavorful steak sauce that keeps them coming back. The two-part service (your steak and fries are served in two rounds) is a fun bonus that guests love. Many mention the friendly and attentive staff, making it a welcoming place even during busy hours. The atmosphere is described as “inviting and energetic” without being overwhelming.

Areas for Improvement

While the simplified menu is a hit for most, diners looking for variety or vegetarian options may want to look elsewhere. Some reviews mention that it can get a bit crowded during peak hours, so reservations are a smart move.

The Bottom Line

For concert-goers craving a fast, filling, and flavorful steak dinner with minimal fuss, Medium Rare is a crowd-pleasing choice close to the action.