Jonathan's Restaurant - New Hyde Park

Classic American Comfort Just Minutes from the Music

Jonathan's Restaurant in New Hyde Park delivers a warm, inviting dining experience with a touch of sophistication. Conveniently situated on Jericho Turnpike, it’s a popular neighborhood spot for locals and visitors alike. With a menu full of classic American favorites, cozy booths, and a polished yet relaxed vibe, it’s the kind of place where you can kick off your night out right—especially if you're heading to a concert nearby.

Why Concert-goers love it

Located just a short drive from several Long Island music venues, Jonathan's is known for its efficient service—great for grabbing a satisfying bite before showtime. The restaurant offers plenty of seating, including a lively bar area and more intimate dining rooms, so you can choose the atmosphere that fits your pre-show mood. It’s also quiet enough to chat without shouting, even during busy hours, making it a great place to connect before the music starts.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends getting together before a big show
• Solo travelers looking for a comfortable and friendly stop
• Couples planning a romantic concert-night dinner
• Fans who enjoy a lively buzz before the event
• Budget-conscious music lovers wanting solid meals without breaking the bank

What People Say

Guests on TripAdvisor and OpenTable often praise the generous portions, friendly service, and consistent food quality. The menu favorites include steak, pasta dishes, and fresh seafood, with many noting how well the kitchen handles special requests. Reviewers also love the classic decor, calling it “upscale casual without being stuffy.”

Areas for Improvement

Some diners mention that the restaurant can get busy during peak hours, so a reservation is a smart move if you're on a timeline. A few reviews also note that while the food is reliable, it may not be adventurous—more of a comfort-food go-to than a culinary surprise.

The Bottom Line

If you're heading to a show and want a dependable, relaxed spot to fuel up before the music, Jonathan’s hits all the right notes.