John's Pizzeria

New York-Style Pizza Tradition Just Steps from the Stage

Located in the heart of the Theater District on West 44th Street, John's Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers and concert-goers alike. Housed in a former church with soaring ceilings and stained-glass windows, this iconic family-style pizzeria offers a true New York experience just a short walk from some of the city’s top music venues. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice before the show or sitting down for a full pie with friends, John's serves up traditional, coal-fired pizza in a spacious, lively setting.

Why Concert-goers love it

Location, location, location—John’s is just minutes from Times Square’s biggest concert halls, making it an ideal pre-show stop. The service is fast and efficient, which means you won’t be late for your set time. The large interior and communal tables make it easy to find a seat, even on busy nights, and the energy inside is always buzzing, perfect for getting into the concert mood.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to split a few pies before heading out
• Solo travelers wanting a classic NYC meal in a friendly spot
• Couples on a romantic weekend who want casual but memorable dining
• Fans seeking a lively atmosphere that matches the buzz of a live show
• Budget-conscious music lovers who want quality without high prices

What People Say

Reviewers rave about the authentic coal-fired crust, calling it “crispy, chewy, and unforgettable.” Many mention the stunning interior, saying the converted church setting adds a special charm. Guests appreciate the quick service and large portions, perfect for sharing. It's especially popular with out-of-town visitors who want a classic NYC pizza experience near the action.

Areas for Improvement

It can get loud and crowded during peak hours, especially before showtimes, so it’s not the best pick for a quiet dinner. Also, be aware—they don’t sell slices, only full pies, which may not suit solo diners looking for a quick bite.

The Bottom Line

John’s Pizzeria delivers iconic New York pizza in a vibrant, convenient location that’s tailor-made for concertgoers looking to fuel up before the show.