Gage & Tollner

Timeless Elegance Just Steps from Brooklyn’s Music Scene

Gage & Tollner is a beautifully restored, historic American restaurant located in Downtown Brooklyn—a quick stroll from some of the borough’s top concert venues. With its gas-lit chandeliers, mahogany paneling, and vintage mirrors, this iconic spot blends old-world charm with a modern culinary experience. Originally opened in 1879, the restaurant has been thoughtfully brought back to life, offering a menu centered on classic American fare with a focus on oysters, chops, and rich, satisfying mains.

Why Concert-goers love it

Whether you're heading to a show at BAM or catching a performance at a nearby venue, Gage & Tollner's central location and efficient service make it a standout choice. The restaurant’s elegant yet welcoming vibe creates the perfect pre-show atmosphere—lively enough to feel special, but relaxed enough to not feel rushed. Reservations are recommended, but the bar area is often available for walk-ins and makes for a great spot to grab a quick bite or cocktail before showtime.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to start the night with oysters and cocktails
• Solo travelers soaking up Brooklyn’s historic charm
• Couples planning a romantic dinner-and-show night out
• Fans who want a lively, upscale pre-show experience
• Budget-conscious music fans who can enjoy happy hour at the bar

What People Say

Guests rave about the beautifully restored interior, calling it “transportive” and “like stepping back in time.” The oyster selection and pork chops earn consistent praise, as do the classic cocktails and attentive staff. Many reviewers recommend it as a perfect spot for a special night out, especially when paired with a concert or show nearby.

Areas for Improvement

While the ambiance is a major draw, some visitors note that it can get a bit loud during peak hours, which might not suit those looking for a quiet meal. Pricing leans toward the upscale side, so it may not be the best fit for fans on a tight budget—though the bar menu offers more accessible options.

The Bottom Line

If you're looking to pair your concert night with a meal that feels like an occasion, Gage & Tollner delivers timeless style, top-notch food, and a great vibe just minutes from Brooklyn’s best venues.