Emmy Squared - Midtown West - NYC

Detroit-Style Pizza with a NYC Twist, Steps from the Stage

Emmy Squared – Midtown West brings bold flavor and casual charm to the Upper West Side, just a quick walk from Lincoln Center and other major NYC concert spots. Known for its crispy-edged Detroit-style pizza and crave-worthy burgers, this spot blends a warm, welcoming vibe with food that hits all the right notes.

The space is modern yet relaxed, with comfort food at the center of the menu — think thick, cheesy pies, loaded sandwiches, and a solid craft beer list. It’s a favorite for locals and visitors alike looking for a satisfying, unfussy meal before or after a show.

Why Concert-goers love it

Location is everything — and Emmy Squared is just minutes from major venues like Lincoln Center, Terminal 5, and Beacon Theatre. You can count on fast, friendly service and a menu that’s ideal for sharing, making it perfect for a quick bite before the music starts. The casual vibe means you don’t have to dress up, and the noise level stays manageable even during peak times.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to share a pizza or two before a concert
• Solo travelers grabbing a burger at the bar
• Couples enjoying a fun, low-key dinner before a show
• Fans who want a lively, energetic space to get hyped before the headliner
• Budget-conscious music lovers who still want great food in a central spot

What People Say

Reviewers love the signature "Colony" pizza with pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey, as well as the famous Le Big Matt burger. Many say it’s "some of the best pizza in NYC" with a crust that’s "crispy on the outside, fluffy inside." The staff gets high marks for being "attentive and fast," and the vibe is consistently described as "cool but not pretentious." It’s also praised for being "perfect for pre-theatre dining" and "great for groups."

Areas for Improvement

Some diners note that seating can be tight during peak hours, and there can be a short wait if you don’t have a reservation. A few reviews mention that the music volume inside can be a bit loud for conversation, but most find it adds to the pre-show energy.

The Bottom Line

For concert-goers craving bold flavors and zero fuss, Emmy Squared Midtown West delivers a perfect pre-show meal just minutes from the music.