Derailed at Hotel Nickel Plate

Stylish American Eats Just Steps from the Stage

Derailed at Hotel Nickel Plate is a sleek, modern American restaurant located in the heart of downtown Fishers. Situated inside the boutique Hotel Nickel Plate, this elevated spot blends upscale comfort food with a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. With stylish interiors, cozy booths, and a curated cocktail menu, it’s a favorite among locals and travelers alike looking to dine in style before or after a show.

Why Concert-goers love it

Just minutes from Fishers' popular event venues, Derailed is a convenient and stylish stop for pre-show dinners or post-concert drinks. The service is efficient and friendly, making it ideal for those on a tighter schedule. Guests love the lively yet comfortable vibe, perfect for getting into concert mode without fighting loud bar noise. Plus, the bar stays open late on weekends, great for winding down after the encore.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for shareable plates and cocktails
• Solo travelers grabbing a bite before a bucket-list performance
• Couples on a romantic weekend with dinner and music
• Fans wanting a buzzy pre-show gathering spot
• Budget-conscious music lovers appreciating quality food at fair prices

What People Say

Guests on TripAdvisor and OpenTable rave about the fresh takes on American classics, like the smoked brisket grilled cheese and crispy Brussels sprouts. Reviewers also highlight the craft cocktails and the warm, attentive staff. Many mention the restaurant’s modern design and relaxed ambiance as perfect for kicking off a fun night out. Locals love that it’s a hidden gem inside a hotel, giving it a cool, tucked-away vibe.

Areas for Improvement

Some reviewers note that the menu isn’t extensive, so if you’re a picky eater, your options might feel a bit limited. On weekends, it can get busy—especially when there’s a show in town—so making a reservation is a smart move.

The Bottom Line

With its chic setting, quick service, and prime location near Fishers’ live music spots, Derailed is an ideal pre- or post-concert dining destination for music fans of all kinds.