Connolly's Pub and Restaurant - 45th

Classic Irish-American Fare in the Heart of Midtown

Connolly's Pub and Restaurant – 45th is a warm and welcoming Irish-American pub located just a short walk from Times Square and many of New York City's most iconic concert venues. With its traditional mahogany bar, exposed brick walls, and friendly atmosphere, this two-story Midtown spot blends classic pub charm with the energy of the Theater District.

Serving up generous portions of American comfort food with an Irish twist, Connolly’s is known for its hearty burgers, fish and chips, shepherd's pie, and wide selection of beers on tap. Whether you're in the mood for a quick pint or a sit-down dinner before a show, the vibe here is casual but polished — perfect for business casual attire or just looking sharp for a night out.

Why Concert-goers love it

Just minutes from Broadway theaters and major music venues, Connolly's is a go-to for pre-show dining. Guests highlight the speedy service, even during peak hours, and the spacious upstairs seating that can accommodate groups without feeling cramped. The lively but not overwhelming atmosphere makes it easy to chat over dinner without missing the buzz of the city.

With a full bar and kitchen open late, it’s also a great post-show stop for a nightcap or a bite before heading home.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a fun, relaxed meet-up before the show
• Solo travelers who want a friendly bar with good food and a welcoming vibe
• Couples making a romantic weekend of live music and city lights
• Fans who want a lively pre-show energy without the chaos
• Budget-conscious music lovers who appreciate solid value and big portions

What People Say

Reviews from TripAdvisor and OpenTable often mention the attentive staff, quick seating, and the pub’s ability to handle crowds without compromising quality. Many call it a “hidden gem” amid the busyness of Midtown, praising its “great pub food,” “fast kitchen,” and “perfect location for pre-theater or concert dining.”

Visitors love the authentic pub feel and note that it's a favorite of locals and tourists alike. The drink list, especially the Irish whiskey selection and tap beers, also gets plenty of shout-outs.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests mention that it can get a bit noisy during peak hours, especially downstairs by the bar. Others note that while the food is solid, it’s not gourmet — but that’s part of the charm. It’s about hearty, satisfying meals over fancy plating.

The Bottom Line

Connolly's Pub – 45th is a friendly, fast, and flavorful Midtown stop that hits all the right notes for concert-goers looking to fuel up before or after the show.