Cilantro

Fresh Flavors and Lively Vibes on the Upper West Side

Just a short walk from some of New York's favorite concert halls, Cilantro is a colorful, casual Mexican restaurant located on Columbus Avenue in the heart of the Upper West Side. Known for its laid-back ambiance and generous portions, it’s an easy-going spot with a touch of festive flair—ideal for a relaxed meal before catching a show.

This neighborhood favorite blends traditional Mexican cuisine with a few Tex-Mex twists, offering up everything from sizzling fajitas to refreshing margaritas. With friendly service and a vibrant dining room, Cilantro draws locals and visitors alike looking for a satisfying and affordable bite in the city.

Why Concert-goers love it

Whether you're heading to a performance at Lincoln Center or catching a live band nearby, Cilantro delivers what concert-goers need: fast, attentive service, a buzzing atmosphere, and a menu that's both crowd-pleasing and comforting. The noise level is lively but not overwhelming, making it a great place for pre-show energy without needing to shout across the table. Many reviewers note it's easy to get in and out in under an hour—perfect when you're watching the clock before curtain call.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to share nachos and margaritas before the show
• Solo travelers grabbing a quick bite at the bar
• Couples enjoying a casual, flavorful dinner date
• Fans wanting a lively spot to build excitement before a concert
• Budget-conscious concert-goers who want value without sacrificing quality

What People Say

According to reviews on TripAdvisor and OpenTable, diners love Cilantro’s friendly staff, generous portion sizes, and consistently tasty dishes. The margaritas get high marks, and the fajitas and tacos are frequently mentioned as must-tries. Many guests appreciate the restaurant's casual vibe and fast-paced service, especially when dining before a show.

Areas for Improvement

While most guests enjoy the upbeat atmosphere, some mention that the dining room can get a bit cramped during peak hours. A few reviewers noted that the decor is more functional than fancy—so if you’re looking for fine dining, this might not be your spot. But for a fun, flavorful meal, it hits the mark.

The Bottom Line

If you’re after bold flavors, quick service, and a festive atmosphere that gets you in the mood for live music, Cilantro is a top pick on the Upper West Side.