Caruso's Grocery - DC

Classic Italian Comfort Just Steps from DC's Music Scene

Caruso's Grocery is a cozy, old-school Italian-American restaurant tucked inside The Roost on Capitol Hill. Just a short ride from major concert venues, this warm, inviting spot serves up nostalgic, red-sauce classics in a setting that feels straight out of a vintage movie scene. Think white tablecloths, dim lighting, family-style hospitality, and a menu full of hearty favorites.

Modeled after your favorite neighborhood Italian joint, Caruso’s brings a timeless charm with dishes like chicken parmigiana, rigatoni alla vodka, and house-made meatballs that taste just like Nonna used to make. The vibe is relaxed yet refined, striking that perfect balance for a satisfying dinner before the show.

Why Concert-goers love it

Caruso’s is just a few minutes’ drive or Metro ride from concert hotspots around Capitol Hill and Navy Yard, making it a convenient stop before the music starts. The restaurant’s cozy booths and attentive service mean you won’t be rushed, but you also won’t be late. Many diners note that staff are happy to pace the meal around your showtime. It’s also quiet enough for conversation—ideal if you're catching up with friends before a loud night out.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to share pasta and laughs
• Solo travelers craving a comforting plate of Italian before a big night
• Couples making a romantic weekend out of a concert date
• Fans who want a fun, slightly retro atmosphere to kick off the night
• Budget-conscious music lovers who appreciate generous portions and fair prices

What People Say

Diners rave about the authentic Italian-American flavors, warm service, and generous portions. The chicken parm and garlic bread are frequently called out as must-tries. Several reviewers mention the nostalgic vibe and well-executed cocktails as added bonuses. It's also a local favorite for feeling like a “hidden gem” despite its growing popularity.

Areas for Improvement

Because of its growing reputation, reservations are highly recommended—especially on weekends or when there’s a big concert in town. A few guests mention that the menu isn’t extensive, so picky eaters may want to check options beforehand. And while the vibe is charmingly old-school, it may not suit those looking for something ultra-trendy or modern.

The Bottom Line

If you’re after classic Italian comfort food and a relaxed vibe before heading to a show, Caruso’s Grocery hits all the right notes.