Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen - Upper Arlington

Laid-back Italian Fare Just Minutes from Columbus Concert Venues

Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen in Upper Arlington is a cozy, casual Italian spot known for its house-made stromboli, hand-tossed pizzas, and warm service. Tucked just off W Lane Ave, it’s a local favorite with a neighborhood feel—less than 15 minutes from several of Columbus’s top concert venues. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite before a show or unwinding after, Carsonie’s offers a welcoming, unfussy atmosphere with delicious comfort food that hits the spot.

Why Concert-goers love it

Quick service and a relaxed vibe make Carsonie’s ideal for pre-show dining. With generous portions and a menu full of crowd-pleasers—think garlic knots, baked pasta, and their signature strombolis—it’s easy to satisfy your hunger without breaking the bank. The location is close enough to major music venues to make it a convenient stop, yet far enough to avoid the post-show crowds. Plus, it’s usually quiet enough to enjoy conversation without shouting over the noise.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for shareable plates and a casual setting
• Solo travelers wanting a low-key, satisfying meal
• Couples on a romantic music-filled weekend
• Fans seeking a fun, pre-show meet-up spot
• Budget-conscious music lovers who want hearty portions without the high price tag

What People Say

Reviewers rave about the freshly made strombolis and classic pizza options, with many noting the “friendly staff” and “welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.” Regulars appreciate the consistent quality and how it’s “never too loud” to enjoy a meal. The Italian sub and pasta dishes also get high marks for flavor and portion size. Guests also love that service is “fast and attentive,” making it easy to dine and dash to your show on time.

Areas for Improvement

While most feedback is positive, a few diners note that the décor feels a bit “old-school” and could use a refresh. Others mention that the parking lot can get tight during peak hours, so plan to arrive a bit early if you're on a schedule.

The Bottom Line

If you're in the mood for classic Italian comfort food in a laid-back setting before heading to a concert, Carsonie’s delivers flavorful fare, great value, and quick service in just the right location.