Carole's Cheesecake Cafe

Comfort Food & Cheesecake Just Steps from the Stage

Carole's Cheesecake Cafe is a cozy, casual eatery tucked along Cumberland Street in Toronto's Yorkville neighborhood. Known for its rich selection of homemade cheesecakes and comforting American classics, this café combines a laid-back atmosphere with the charm of a local favorite. It’s an easy stroll from several major music venues, making it a sweet stop before or after a show.

Why Concert-goers love it

With its quick service and no-fuss vibe, Carole's is a great option for concert-goers looking to grab something satisfying without missing the opening act. The menu leans toward comfort food favorites — think hearty sandwiches, salads, and a rotating cheesecake selection that steals the show. The café stays relatively quiet, making it a good place to fuel up without battling noise before heading into a loud venue.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends sharing slices of cheesecake before the show
• Solo travelers wanting a relaxed bite in a welcoming space
• Couples enjoying a cozy pre- or post-concert treat
• Fans looking for a chill, no-reservation-needed option
• Budget-conscious music lovers wanting value without sacrificing flavor

What People Say

Diners rave about the decadent desserts, especially the cheesecake, which many call the best in the city. The café’s friendly staff and quiet, comfy ambiance also earn high marks. Visitors appreciate the reasonable prices and the fact that it’s a hidden gem in a busy part of town.

Areas for Improvement

The café’s decor can feel a bit dated, and seating is limited during busier times. While service is usually prompt, it’s not the place if you're seeking an upscale dining experience. And if you're in a rush, it’s best to ask how long dessert orders will take, as some cheesecakes are served chilled and plated to order.

The Bottom Line

If you're heading to a concert and craving a laid-back spot with rich comfort food and legendary cheesecake, Carole's Cheesecake Cafe is a sweet pick that won’t disappoint.