Butter Midtown

Stylish American Dining in the Heart of Midtown

Butter Midtown blends sleek sophistication with rustic charm, offering a chic yet relaxed setting in the vibrant Theater District of New York City. Helmed by celebrity chef Alex Guarnaschelli, the restaurant features a seasonal Contemporary American menu that reflects local ingredients and bold flavors. Just a short walk from iconic concert venues and Broadway theaters, it's an ideal choice for music lovers looking for a memorable meal before the show.

Why Concert-goers love it

Butter Midtown hits the sweet spot for pre-show dining. Its central location makes it incredibly convenient for concertgoers heading to nearby venues. The restaurant’s layout includes both intimate booths and larger communal tables, providing a lively yet not overly noisy atmosphere. Service is known for being attentive and timely, so you can enjoy a full meal without worrying about curtain time. For those on a tighter schedule, the bar area offers a more casual, quick-bite experience with a great wine and cocktail list.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking for a fun and stylish spot to gather before a show
• Solo travelers wanting a high-quality meal at the bar
• Couples making a romantic night of it with elegant ambiance and creative cuisine
• Fans seeking energy and a vibrant pre-show buzz
• Budget-conscious music lovers who don’t mind treating themselves to a splurge-worthy dinner

What People Say

Diners rave about the standout dishes like the truffle pasta and perfectly cooked steaks. The ambiance is often described as “sexy” and “theatrical,” with leather banquettes and dramatic lighting that match the Midtown buzz. Many visitors appreciate the balance between upscale dining and a relaxed, welcoming vibe. The cocktail program also gets high marks, with creative, balanced drinks that impress even seasoned New Yorkers.

Areas for Improvement

Some reviewers note that prices can be a bit steep, especially for appetizers and cocktails. While most guests find the service friendly, a few mention occasional slowdowns during peak pre-show hours—so arriving a bit earlier is a smart move. Also, the restaurant can get busy, so reservations are highly recommended.

The Bottom Line

Butter Midtown is a stylish, centrally located choice for concert-goers seeking a flavorful, upscale dining experience just steps from the action.