Butcher and Banker NYC

Underground Elegance Meets Classic Steakhouse in Midtown

Set in a restored 1930s bank vault beneath the iconic New Yorker Hotel, Butcher and Banker NYC is a modern steakhouse with a vintage twist. Located right in Midtown Manhattan, just steps from Penn Station and major concert venues, it offers a unique blend of bold flavors and historic charm. With its speakeasy-style entrance and moody underground ambiance, this spot delivers a high-end yet approachable dining experience for meat lovers and music fans alike.

Why Concert-goers love it

Butcher and Banker sits a short walk from Madison Square Garden and other key music venues, making it an ideal pre-show stop. The vibe is lively but not too loud, so you can enjoy conversation before the concert energy kicks in. Diners praise the attentive service and efficiency, which helps you enjoy a full meal without stressing about the clock. A strong cocktail menu and hearty entrees make it a great place to fuel up for a night of music.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to toast the night with steaks and cocktails
• Solo travelers wanting a memorable meal in a unique setting
• Couples planning a romantic evening before a show
• Fans seeking a spirited pre-show atmosphere with great food
• Budget-conscious music lovers who want upscale quality without over-the-top prices

What People Say

Guests rave about the signature steaks and creative side dishes, with many recommending the filet mignon and truffle mac & cheese. The vault setting is frequently described as "cool," "unique," and "Instagram-worthy." Many reviews highlight the friendly staff who are quick to offer recommendations and keep things moving for those on a schedule. The bar scene is also a hit, especially for those grabbing drinks before a concert.

Areas for Improvement

Some guests mention that the speakeasy entrance can be a bit tricky to find at first—look for the discreet staircase in the New Yorker Hotel lobby. Prices are on the higher side, especially for drinks, but most agree the quality justifies the cost. During peak hours, reservations are recommended to avoid a wait.

The Bottom Line

If you're headed to a concert in Midtown and want standout steaks in a one-of-a-kind setting, Butcher and Banker NYC hits all the right notes.