BlackFly - St Augustine Customer Reviews
Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of BlackFly - St Augustine?
Write a review
BlackFly - St Augustine is a coastal-inspired seafood spot located on Anastasia Boulevard, just a short hop from St. Augustine’s popular concert venues and the historic downtown area. With its casual dress code and upscale beach-town style, it’s the kind of place where flip-flops meet fine wine. The menu leans heavily into fresh seafood and local flavors, with a focus on high-quality ingredients and creative plating. The colorful interior, adorned with art and fly-fishing décor, adds to its relaxed yet elevated vibe.
BlackFly is a convenient stop for a pre-show dinner, located just over the Bridge of Lions from the heart of the action. Guests love that it strikes the right balance between lively and laid-back — it’s not too loud, making it easy to enjoy conversation before heading to a show. Service is consistently praised as fast and attentive, which helps when you're watching the clock. While there’s no official pre-show menu, the kitchen moves efficiently and offers plenty of dishes that are satisfying without being too heavy.
Reviewers rave about the fresh fish specials, creative appetizers like conch fritters and tuna tacos, and the charming, Florida-inspired ambiance. Many call out the knowledgeable staff and well-crafted drink list. Several diners mention it’s a favorite stop before events, noting that parking is easy and the location is ideal for beating the pre-show rush.
Some guests have noted that the dining area can feel a bit tight during peak hours, and while the menu is seafood-forward, options for picky eaters or non-seafood fans are more limited. That said, the staff is usually happy to help with modifications when possible.
If you're headed to a show and want a fresh, flavorful meal in a relaxed setting just minutes away, BlackFly is a solid bet for concert-goers who crave quality seafood and easy vibes.
Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of BlackFly - St Augustine?
Write a review