Menu

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime, 23 E 40th St., New York

4.7
RESTAURANT RATING: 
WONDERFUL
4.7 out of 5 (255 Ratings)
Powered By Opentable
0.6 miles The Morgan Library and Museum
About Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
The Spotlight on Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

Classic Steakhouse Elegance in Midtown Manhattan

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime blends timeless New York sophistication with a modern edge, located just steps from Bryant Park and a short walk from several major concert venues. With its dark wood interiors, white tablecloths, and soaring ceilings, it delivers a luxe yet welcoming vibe that suits both special occasions and pre-show indulgence. The menu is packed with expertly aged steaks, fresh seafood, and classic sides, all served in an upscale, smart casual setting.

Why Concert-goers love it

Location is everything—and Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is less than 10 minutes from top venues like Madison Square Garden and Radio City Music Hall. The atmosphere is lively but not loud, making it easy to enjoy conversation before a show. Service is prompt and professional, helping diners enjoy a high-quality meal without the rush. While there’s no specific pre-show menu, the kitchen is accommodating and fast, especially for early reservations.

Who this Restaurant is great for

  • Groups of friends looking to share a bottle of wine and a porterhouse
  • Solo travelers wanting to treat themselves before a big concert
  • Couples on a romantic weekend getaway
  • Fans seeking a classy, energetic pre-show vibe
  • Budget-conscious music lovers who want upscale dining for a special night (but be prepared to splurge a bit)

What People Say

Diners on OpenTable and TripAdvisor rave about the perfectly cooked steaks, generous portions, and attentive service. The Prime Rib Eye and Chilean Sea Bass are frequent favorites, and the ambiance is often described as "old-school New York luxury" without being stuffy. Many guests comment on how smoothly the dining experience runs, even when the restaurant is full.

Areas for Improvement

It’s not the most budget-friendly spot, so concert-goers on a tight wallet may want to keep this as a splurge option. Some reviewers mention that it can get busy around peak dinner hours—so making a reservation is a must, especially before a show.

The Bottom Line

If you’re looking to start your concert night with top-tier steaks and classic NYC ambiance, Benjamin Steakhouse Prime delivers a memorable experience just minutes from the music.

Average Price
$30 and under
Cuisine
Steakhouse
Dress Code
Smart Casual
Opening Hours
Lunch
Mon-Fri 11:30 am-3:45 pm
Dinner
Mon-Sat 4:00 pm-11:00 pm

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime Customer Reviews

Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of Benjamin Steakhouse Prime?

Write a review

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is #344 of 14718 things to do in New York City

1 of 5 stars1 out of 5
By: Darin N
Sun 8 Jun, 2025
l It’s become a tradition for the last 25 years to go to one or two steakhouses every time I’m in NYC. I’m always on the hunt for an excellent steak. This past trip I was talked into going to Benjamin...

Read Full Review
3 of 5 stars3 out of 5
By: LG-3691, Upper Montclair, New Jersey
Wed 4 Dec, 2024
l We were 6 on a Thursday nite. Conveniently located near Grand Central . This place is huge and beyond too loud. So loud I could speak to the person next to me but not across the table. Tables are...

Read Full Review
2 of 5 stars2 out of 5
By: 466MikeS, San Antonio, Texas
Fri 22 Nov, 2024
l Shared the porterhouse for 3. It was one of the worst pieces of meat I have had at a good steakhouse. It was prepared correctly but the meat itself was fatty and tough. Very disappointing. The...

Read Full Review
Write a Review of Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Reference (Required)
Your Name (Required)
Your City
Your Email Address (Required)
Your overall rating of Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
What was good?
What was bad?
Your review of Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime 23 E 40th St., New York