1653 Pizza Company

Classic New York Pizza with a Modern Twist in the Heart of Huntington

1653 Pizza Company is a casual, no-frills Italian spot located right in downtown Huntington, making it a convenient stop before or after a show. With a focus on high-quality ingredients and creative pies, it blends traditional New York-style pizza with artisanal flair. Expect a laid-back vibe, friendly service, and quick turnaround—perfect for concert-goers on a schedule.

Why Concert-goers love it

Just a short walk or drive from several popular music venues in Huntington, 1653 Pizza Company is a go-to for fans looking to fuel up without missing the opening act. The atmosphere is chill and low-pressure, and the efficient service means you can be in and out in time for your seat. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a full pie with friends, it's an easy pre-show choice.

Who this Restaurant is great for

• Groups of friends looking to share a pie and a few laughs before the show
• Solo travelers grabbing a quick bite without needing reservations
• Couples seeking a casual and cozy dinner before a night out
• Fans wanting a lively pre-show space with a local vibe
• Budget-conscious music fans watching both their wallet and the clock

What People Say

Reviewers rave about the crispy-yet-chewy crusts, generous toppings, and fresh ingredients. The creative specialty pies like the “Bee Sting” (hot honey and pepperoni) and white truffle mushroom pizza get special shoutouts. Customers also appreciate the friendly staff and clean, comfortable setting that’s perfect for a quick bite or casual dinner before heading to a concert.

Areas for Improvement

Some diners mention that the seating is limited, especially during peak hours, so it might not be ideal for large groups without a little planning. Others noted that while the pizza is stellar, the small selection of non-pizza menu items might leave you wanting more variety if you're not in the mood for a slice.

The Bottom Line

If you're looking for quick, delicious, and affordable Italian food just steps from Huntington's music scene, 1653 Pizza Company hits all the right notes.