Exceptional

Passable

We loved all the history...

Liked: Location was perfect. Property lacked total maintenance.
Disliked: It was ok

Everything was as we hoped

Liked: History, location,
Disliked: All good

If you just want to...

Liked: Lovely old, OLD building; it's the kind of place you could stay an extra night and do nothing for that day but just enjoy the place where you're staying! Enjoyed chatting with the hostess after check-in and with fellow guests at breakfast.
Disliked: Being picky maybe, but there's not a lot to see and do unless you're into Mormon history. But then, learning is always a good thing!

Exceptional

Good experience

Liked: Location
Disliked: Breakfast was always later then the time I asked

Loved the history and the...

Liked: I liked the history, the memorabilia around the Inn, its authenticity and historic relics, location, informative papers explaining events and conditions at that time, the comfortable bed and the two young girls who greeted us who were very friendly.
Disliked: I was very disappointed, even somewhat shocked, at the poor upkeep of the exterior and grounds (lack of inviting landscape) of the Inn. It almost turned us away fearing that the inside would be just as unkept. Fortunately, inside was clean. It could be very pretty with all the flowers and greenery that grows in that area. It doesn't do the Inn and its place in LDS history justice to have it look so run down from the outside.

We competely enjoyed out stay...

Liked: The location was excellent for visiting the sites in Old Nauvoo. The history of the Willard Richards Inn drew us to the location.
Disliked: Getting to the Inn after 7 PM was hard as the streets were blocked off due to the pageants. We had a private restroom down the hall, but we survived just fine.