The Tillary Hotel Brooklyn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Lanika Sun, 13 July 2025
Pleasant
Liked: The location
Disliked: No restaurant, on-site patio bar expensive watered-down drinks
Laura Sun, 13 July 2025
Bad experience
Liked: Good location for our needs.
Disliked: The overall condition of the hotel is rundown- carpets dirty, decor dated etc. requested a room off Flatbush which was accompanied. The room however was 79 degree at 9 pm. Let staff know the following morning and was assured it would be corrected. We stayed 3 nights and our room ranged from 79-83 degrees- not comfortable. Room have something on the ceiling above the bed, our one coffee cup was never picked up and cleaned for all three days. We’ve stayed here many times but this was a bad experience all the way around.
Leon Sat, 12 July 2025
Passable
William Sat, 12 July 2025
Very good
Evelyn Sat, 12 July 2025
Exceptional
Yoshiko Fri, 11 July 2025
Disappointing
Liked: The location was ok
Disliked: NoisyOur request of cleaning room was not met
Aimee Thu, 10 July 2025
Good
Liked: Good location and comfortable bed
Tristan Thu, 10 July 2025
Very good. relaxing
Siobhan Wed, 9 July 2025
Never again! The stay from...
Liked: location. That is all
Disliked: I had a terrible experience at this hotel. When I arrived late, there was no one to assist me with my bags, and I had quite a few. I put them on a trolley, but it was so unsteady that it rolled in every direction. I checked in after 2 a.m., completely exhausted. To make matters worse, I was assigned to a room that was already occupied. Imagine my shock walking in on a couple in the middle of having sex! I screamed, they screamed, and I quickly ran out.I returned to the front desk with my trolley and all my luggage, and the receptionist's system showed the room as unoccupied. She had to call someone to find out who was actually in the room. Eventually, I was given a new room. However, when I entered, it was pitch black. I turned on the switches, but nothing happened. When I called downstairs, the receptionist said someone would come right away to check, but no one ever arrived.At this point, it was nearly 3 a.m., and after traveling for over 30 hours, I had to get ready for bed and take a shower using the flashlight on my phone. I ended up checking all the lamps myself to see if I could get them working, but the main light never turned on. A repairman finally arrived the next night, after I had gone to the front desk twice throughout the day. It was truly a stay from hell.
Jakub Tue, 8 July 2025
Bad
Disliked: I do not recommend this hotel. After my stay, the property failed to return my deposit. I contacted them several times through private messages, and although they replied saying they would "look into it," they never followed up or took any action. It has been 3 weeks, and I still haven't received my money back.The lack of transparency and responsibility is extremely disappointing. Be careful if you're booking here — you might not get your deposit back.