The Station Hotel

Superb

Exceptional

Liked: Beautiful hotel, the rooms were lovely and the staff were great. We’d love to return.

Exceptional

Liked: Fantastic and very helpful staff, we would stay here again
Disliked: N/a

Would definitely recommend

Liked: The staff are all very friendly and extremely knowledgeable of their whiskies. The food is great and I would recommend the tasting menu along with the Whisky flight. Rooms were spacious and clean. With plenty of space and tables in the courtyard to enjoy the sun.
Disliked: It was a little warm to sleep. Given the rarity of 25+ celcius days in Scotland I don't forsee it being a problem in most instances.

Superb

Liked: Lovely place with good food

Fine for the purpose of...

Liked: The hotel was nice. Toots bar was nothing special, far preferred the whisky bar to sit in. It was good for breakfast but it just felt like any bar and not wonderful to sit in for a nice meal. Food was good though. Lovely and hot dinner. Breakfast was fine. Hotel room was comfy but slightly dated however we had just come from a contemporary 4star hotel so probably made it look slightly old fashioned. Probably suited the style.
Disliked: It was not a criticism as such but the staff although fine, helpful and friendly didn't particularly have a 'managing/working in a 4 star hotel' feel to them. I was a little confused about who was in charge, they seemed to have their friends or people they knew in the bar - couldn't quite work it out but it just felt slightly odd for the calibre of hotel. They were efficient though and easy to deal with so as I say not a criticism just an observation.

Very good

A most enjoyable break.

Liked: Location for our stay. The restaurant meals were very good.
Disliked: No lift

A nice one night stay...

Liked: Lovely little hotel. Nice and close for visits to Macallan and Glenfiddich. It was nice having the whisky room to come back to after the day
Disliked: The immediate area it’s in doesn’t have much going on