The Scotsman Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Erena Sun, 24 August 2025
Exceptional
Majeed Sun, 24 August 2025
Edinburgh is one of the...
Liked: Everything in the hotel was outstanding
Disliked: Nothing
Christopher Sat, 23 August 2025
Lovely hotel, excellent location, really...
Liked: We had a very cool room on the 8th floor, large bed, skylights, great bathroom. The central location of the hotel made it very easy to see all the sights of old Edinburgh.
Disliked: A little awkward getting in and out of the hotel due to the never ending construction on the main street (out of the hotels hands of course).
Jennifer Fri, 22 August 2025
Excellent for visiting Edinburgh.
Liked: The location was excellent for sightseeing & near to the train station. The room was well furnished with lots of room. There was a good choice at breakfast, & the staff were helpful & friendly.
Disliked: Nothing.
Alena Fri, 22 August 2025
Great location, beautiful room and...
Liked: Room was beautiful, spacious, and had great views!
Disliked: This is not the fault of the hotel, but the noise from the street below was pretty loud. Our room was street-side, and the hotel has taken precautions by installing extra windows and heavy drapes, but construction and the vehicles kept running over this metal grate in the road that was VERY annoying. Again, not the hotels fault.
Pamela Thu, 21 August 2025
Very good
Ali Wed, 20 August 2025
Bad
Kamdad Tue, 19 August 2025
Poor
Liked: I didn’t attend the breakfast
Disliked: I would like to share my feedback regarding my recent stay at your hotel. Unfortunately, the experience was not as expected for the following reasons:1.The elevator was not working, and we had to use the stairs throughout our stay, which was very inconvenient.2.The security deposit that was charged has still not been refunded, even though more than 20 days have passed. At check-out, I was informed that the refund would be processed within a week, but I have yet to receive it.I kindly request your assistance in resolving this matter as soon as possible.
Mike Mon, 18 August 2025
Comfortable and convenient
Liked: Attitude of all staff
Disliked: Breakfast room not to standard of rest of hotel
Michael Sun, 17 August 2025
Fantastic Hotel, Fantastic Location, Beautiful...
Liked: Location, size of room, cleanliness, shower
Disliked: I ordered an old fashioned cocktail in the Grande Cafe/bar & it did not taste like any other old fashioned id ever had!I was disappointed-I googled the contents of an old fashioned & asked the server had they all been included.He said they were-but frankly I didn’t believe him & still don’t believe him.For the record I was stone cold sober at the time.