Good

Exceptional

Liked: Everything was perfect

Superb

Exceptional

Great location; great breakfast.

Liked: The breakfast was exceptional. There was a great deal of variety (bangers, tomatoes, eggs, haggis, cold cuts, cheeses, several fresh fruits, pastries, bread/toast, juices, coffe, tea). Only the hot chocolate did not work. However, there was hot chocolate availabe in the lobby almost any time.The location was very good for us. Only one block from Waverly Station, two blocks from Princes Street, etc. It was walking distance (if you're feeling active) to the Castle, the University and Holyrood, even Arthur's Seat (if you're feeling very active).The staff in the lobby were polite and knowledgeable and quite willing to answer my questions.
Disliked: Being American, I'm not used to a single duvee on the bed (no top sheet, no blanket). I have trouble regulating my temperature with only a duvee. The staff did a very good job of keeping the room clean and neat.

Very good

Liked: Good choices available

Beautiful, comfortable hotel

Liked: Wonderful, spacious room with a huge bathroom with a separate toilet, even a bath tub. Shower was great, lovely products to use. The bed was super comfortable, and all in a great position right next to the train station
Disliked: Nothing

Exceptional

Passable

Liked: .