The Roxbury

Very good

A Night at The Roxbury...

Liked: This hotel has so much charm. Everywhere you look there is a custom touch to add to this already beautiful property. There is so much more art than the photos on the listing displays. Every wall has some kind of custom art or theme. It's kitschy in a good way if you're into that like we are. The view of the sun rising over the Catskills was phenomenal and the babbling brook outside the hotel is lovely. Overall, it's a really visually stimulating stay!
Disliked: I have no complaints about the property itself, but the area leaves something to be desired. We thought the beginning of April would show more signs of life as this area is big on spring tourism, but most of the shops and restaurants were still closed for the season. Not anyone's fault, we were just here a bit too early. If you are planning to stay in the off season, I would recommend ensuring you can buy microwavable or ready made meals from a grocery story before arriving.

Superb

Disliked: Wish there were a bit more food options on site at the Stratton falls location. Otherwise our stay was lovely and we loved the cottage we were in.

owners have recently changed- and...

Liked: The staff were lovely.The room was spacious, it was great to have two real comfortable beds (one king and one queen)- as I was staying with a friend.The Motel was conveniently located between two ski hills- Belleyare and Plattekill, and the small village was also nice.about 20 mintues drive to some of the more popular restaurants in the area.
Disliked: We had heard about the Roxbury hotel and decor and were excited to visit. It was unclear when booking on Bookings that in fact we had booked the Motel and not hotel. We had room 1 (the Shagadellic) which is their first ever designed room. While I'm sure the decor of the other rooms may be better, our one just felt like an outdated motel...Breakfast was also included in the steep price, but we had to order it every day in advance, and could only select 4 items that would be delivered to our room (I ordered 2 hard boil eggs and it counted as 2 items...the bagel was small and stale...needless to stay we never bothered to order breakfast after the first attempt). We were also charged a 20$ per day facilitates fee- however we were told some of the facilities were not working. we had to book in advance the use of the hot tub and sauna on the other property- there was very very limited spots and we only managed to go once. our spot was booked for a mere 45 minutes( 10 minutes taken up by explanations) the private hot tub was separated by a bath curtain from the entrance to the building..a bit strange. Overall there was a feeling there was no common space (at the hotel or motel) to just sit and relax, rather we made use of our room. the room was decently sized and equipped, but the bathroom was abnormally small and we could hear the people snoring next door. Also because of the motel style- we could hear the cars pulling out of the driveway in the early morning.For almost 300 USD per night the room, breakfast and overall amenities of the Motel/Hotel just didn't seem worth it.

Very good

Liked: Design

I am highly recommend this...

Liked: Clean, friendly comfortable.
Disliked: The shower in Room 1 wasn’t working, but a staff member kindly offered to move us to a different bigger room. It was a thoughtful and caring gesture.Recommend book the spa in advance..

Superb

We had a very quiet...

Liked: Breakfast in the bag was well organized and a real good idea…. we loved it!!!
Disliked: Can’t think of anything!

Exceptional