The Roseate Edinburgh Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Kate Mon, 9 June 2025
Superb
Liked: Excellent location. Very comfortable and good breakfast. Staff friendly
Najla Fri, 6 June 2025
Superb
Allan Sun, 1 June 2025
Overpriced, NOT a five star,...
Liked: Main hotel has character. Pleasant bar / restaurant area.
Disliked: Two nights for £730 was meant to be a treat for a 5 star experience. This hotel is not 5 star. The service was good at check in, but poor afterwards. The bar staff were inept, served orange juice as a French martini. Bar ran out of glasses! Dinner staff terribly inattentive, no check on our needs, had to chase for basics. Breakfast was ok, but again not 5 star. Accommodation is split across a busy main road. My room was not in main hotel. It was in a featureless extension of an old house across the road. The small 8’x15’ room was classed as superior. It was cramped, hot (no AC) and lacked any character. There was zero view. The walls were paper thin. Normal moving about noise, showers and flushing from adjacent rooms was intrusive. As a 3 star and £180 a night this would be good value. Sadly it is overpriced and certainly under delivered
Karen Sun, 1 June 2025
Exceptional
Sharon Fri, 30 May 2025
Superb
Carolyn Tue, 27 May 2025
Beautiful hotel, furnished with flair
Liked: Breakfast choices were goodLovely bedroom in house, quality linen and pillows
Disliked: Pancakes seemed to be bought in and not made freshNoise from wedding below, would rather have been informed personally, and choice of moving rooms
Yessenia Fri, 23 May 2025
Lovely place to stay, smells...
Liked: The pillows, bed, and comforter were very comfortable. The shower products specifically the “Scot’s pine” scent smelled incredible & even the smell when you walk into the property smells heavenly!! I loved it so much I asked if they sold a candle or room spray in that scent (unfortunately they don’t). I also really appreciated the congratulations card and treats on our bed when we arrived it made our honeymoon feel even more special :) I was also a fan of the cookies in the room. Also the gentleman who checked us in and showed me to my room was very nice and personable helping us with recommendations on where to go during our stay.
Disliked: The toilet takes a while to flush & I wish the room had AC, it got a little hot in there at times
Anonymous Thu, 22 May 2025
Lovely stay! Perfect for a...
Liked: Amazing rooms with good toiletries and lots of towels, good location with excellent bus services outside and quickly into the city centre. Helpful & friendly staff, and nice to have the later than usual check out times.
Disliked: Not much to dislike! We didn’t try the restaurant or breakfast, so cannot comment
Laura-anna Wed, 21 May 2025
Exceptional
Stephen Mon, 19 May 2025
Superb