Would definitely return

Liked: Great food, and very friendly efficient staff. Stockbridge is a really interesting area, so there were locals and tourists in the hotel bar, with a very warm vibe. They brought 2 glasses of fizz to the room to celebrate our wedding anniversary, which was lovely.
Disliked: Would have preferred a super king sized bed, rather than the king that was there, and it was too soft for my preference.

Good

The best hotel we stayed...

Liked: The shower was the best we've had in just about any hotel in the world.The veggie Scottish breakfast was superb.The staff were very welcoming and accommodating and professional. Really great.The beds were very comfortable, better than most in Scotland.
Disliked: It would be nice to have more "basic" dining options on the menu. Everything was very "fancy". Sometimes you just want soup and a sandwich, you know? Or maybe just a plain salad without chicken, salmon, etc. To be fair, this seems to be the norm in Scotland, and is the same feedback I'm giving to most restaurants. Not everything needs to be haute cuisine, fit for a cooking show.

Very dissatisfied please amend your...

Liked: Nothing
Disliked: The property is erroneous described as a luxury 4star hotel which it definitely is not. It is a busy pub with rooms above. Miss selling and misrepresented. It does not deserve the rating given on your site. Hugely overpriced and disappointed

Not cheap but a really...

Liked: Room was beautiful. Superb bathroom. Great location. Nice food. Staff were friendly.
Disliked: Very little hotel parking so had to pay for street parking.Bathrobes need to be softer and MUCH more generously sized.

Very good

A little idyll once you...

Liked: The room was fabulous - spacious, well presented and comfortable
Disliked: Extremely noisy bar downstairs with a guy vomiting against a tree in front of the hotel as we entered

Exceptional

A beautifully decorated boutique hotel...

Liked: Beautifully decorated spacious bedroom and hotel location.
Disliked: Nothing